Putin enters the Hitler category

Michael Emerson

Op-ed No. 4/2022

Until now Hitler has been branded as the most extreme incarnation of evil, to the point that he has remained in the history books only, and not heard of in comparisons with any other living personality. That now changes with Putin.

 

Paradoxically Putin has himself opened up the Hitler question by seeking to justify his invasion of Ukraine in order to de-Nazify its leadership, responsible for genocide against Russians in the Donbas. The absurdity of these allegations illustrates the ideological and factual bankruptcy of his attempt to justify war.  

 

This subject is of such gravity that it needs to be considered with clinical objectivity, taking the vocabulary defining the Hitler regime word by word.  

 

Dictatorship. No question for both, through to the leader isolated in his bunker, in contact with just a few members of his inner circle.

 

Militarist. Putin has invested in a huge build-up of his military for the beginning of his presidency in 2000, as did Hitler in his time.

 

Irredentist. Putin has ideologized the Russian world (Russki Mir) to embrace regions in other countries where there are Russian minorities. His occupation of the Donbas and annexation of Crimea to defend Russian people bears comparison with Hitler’s seizure of the Czechoslovak Sudetenland in 1938. 

 

Propaganda. Modern technologies have allowed Putin to go beyond Hitler with information war and cyber attacks.

 

Injustice. Both Hitler and Putin had or have their grievances, Hitler over the humiliation of post-WW I reparations, Putin over broken oral promises given to Gorbachev excluding NATO expansion. But grounds for a ‘just war’? No.

 

Strategic lying. Putin’s voices (Lavrov, Peskov, Zakharova) kept up parroting denial and protests over “Russophobic hysteria” in response to US warnings about preparations for invasion until the day before it happened on 24 February. Like Hitler at Munich. 

 

Appeasement – by the West. Biden said the US would not intervene with ‘boots on the ground’. Macron and Scholtz made last pilgrimages to Moscow to plead for peace. Indeed Chamberlain and Daladier in Munich in 1938 have become the most cited comparison so far.

 

Genocide. Hitler’s Holocaust saw murder of 6 million Jews. Putin’s war in Chechnya in 1999-2000 saw indiscriminate destruction of urban centres, costing around 25,000 lives. His military intervention in Syria since 2015 contributed hugely to the total displacement of 5 million refugees and half a million deaths. He has semi-rehabilitated Stalin whose purges in 1938-39 cost around a million lives, after the Holodomor in 1932-33 when 3 million Ukrainians were starved to death. Stalin added genocidal deportations of  Estonians, Latvians and Lithuanians during and after WW II.

 

Assassination. Hitler was subject to numerous assassination attempts. For Putin it is the other way round, his regime having attempted the political assassination of Navalny in 2021, while the murderer of Nemtsov in 2015 was never found; plus extra-territorial assassinations attempted (Skripal, 2018) or achieved (Litvinenko, 2006).  

 

Blitzkrieg. For military historians the invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 with a large fraction of Russia’s entire army will stand in comparison with the Reich’s invasion of Belgium and France in 1940.

 

Occupation. If there is to be occupation, a discussed scenario sees a division between the left bank Dnipro, with the right bank left apart. Recall France in 1940-42, divided into a small contiguous region annexed (Alsace-Lorraine), Paris and the north and west occupied, with the semi-puppet Vichy regime to the south-east. 

 

Resistance. Already the Ukrainian resistance takes shape with the arming of volunteer territorial defence units, and people in the streets preparing Molotov cocktails. What order would Putin give to his occupying troops, when they suffer casualties? The Hitler playbook says reprisals, Putin’s nightmare scenario. 

 

Rationality or insanity. Is Putin an entirely rational actor, or somewhat mentally deranged? The question has been much debated over Hitler. Putin’s speeches contain are a curious mix of mastery of detail and absurdity, like on 21 February “in 1991 Russia was robbed”, when Yeltsin agreed with his Ukrainian and Belarus counterparts on independence for all three of them and dissolution of the Soviet Union. Putin’s build-up of long convoys of tanks, artillery and military transport now heading for Kyiv point to a demented reaction after his miscalculation that Ukraine would simply surrender. If he goes further ahead with a devastating destruction of Kyiv and other cities it is certain that Russia will be entrenched as the enemy of the Ukrainian people for 100 years, and Putin until the end of his days - no longer the brilliant strategic chess player, or even a rational actor, just someone who had tragically locked himself into a dynamic that ends with crime against humanity.   

 

No comparisons are ever perfect. But the points of comparability are many and big. 

 

Putin has pushed the European Union takes steps that were until a few days ago unimaginable. The Hitler legacy had made of the EU the most pacifist major power in the world. On 27 February the President of the Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, announced the decision to fund 500 million euro of lethal weapons to help the Ukrainian people fight. She further overturned years of the EU’s denial of Ukraine’s pleas for membership perspectives with “They are one of us and we want them in”. Zelensky followed with a request for immediate accession.

 

But there is one huge overarching difference between Putin and Hitler. Putin has nuclear weapons at his fingertips. Hitler had a nuclear research programme, but not time enough to produce the atom bomb. 

 

Nonetheless Putin goes ahead with nuclear blackmail. On 24 February he said “whoever might be tempted to meddle in the ongoing events, … should know Russia’s response will be immediate and lead to consequences you have never encountered in your history. … All necessary decisions in this regard have been made”. On 28 February he put his nuclear forces on “special alert”.  Here Putin is overtaking Hitler.

 

Where does this leave us? The Ukrainians fight courageously and impressively at home. In Russia it will have to be for the ordinary decent people there to get rid of their dictator by means we cannot yet see. Already in August 2021 a Levada poll showed that a 66% majority of Russians prefer to be “in a country with a high standard of living, albeit not one of the most militarily strong countries in the world”, compared to only 32% who would prefer Russia to be “a great power that other countries respect and fear”. What would these data show now, if the people could see what is happening? So far the propaganda and censorship machines are hiding the truth from much of the population, and the start of anti-war demonstrations in the streets has been repressed. But this time the regime will not be able to stop the flow - through social media. As Putin’s war of occupation becomes ever more gruesome, and as sanctions deepen their bite, the Russian people will come to understand what has been happening and draw the inevitable conclusion. All families still have memories of what it was like living in a rotten state regime, protected by minimal information and maximum repression, and even how the end can come quite suddenly. 

 

Comments ()

  1. wan785 16 february 2023, 09:32 # 0
    Where does this leave us? 印度神油The Ukrainians fight courageously and impressively 必利勁 at home. In Russia it will have to be for the ordinary decent people there to get rid
    威而鋼哪裡買 of their dictator by means we cannot yet see.
    1. SEO 01 march 2023, 13:57 # 0
      I would like to say that this blog really convinced me to do it! Thanks, very good post. Flights in pakistan
      1. Sifa 14 march 2023, 12:02 # 0
        Sifa offers an amazing collection of ready to wear dresses online in Pakistan. Explore the best quality women's dresses online at sifa. Order your favorite dresses online today.
        1. Metro Shoes 14 march 2023, 13:49 # 0
          Metro shoes offer their customers the highest quality women shoes, Formal shoes, Casual shoes, and sandals for women and men. Get the best available men’s sandals in Pakistan, today. So, buy only the best shoes online from Metro shoes. We bring you only the highest quality men’s shoes.
          1. Jazmin 14 march 2023, 15:34 # 0
            Looking for elegant and trendy Net Dresses? Jazmin Clothing has got you covered! Our latest collection of net dresses for ladies is designed to make you feel confident and stylish. So, grab your favorite net dress online at the best prices.
            1. Jazmin 14 march 2023, 15:36 # 0
              Looking for elegant and trendy Net Dresses? Jazmin Clothing has got you covered! Our latest collection of net dresses for ladies is designed to make you feel confident and stylish. So, grab your favorite net dress online at the best prices.
              1. percetakan rawamangun 14 march 2023, 19:57 # 0
                percetakan jakarta timur This is really great stuff for an article, this topic is very interesting. Keep it up with this line of content, thanks for sharing this post! ( percetakan jakarta timur & tempat print online )

                1. Belive 16 march 2023, 10:03 # 0
                  Belive is a top Women s Signature Camisole brand in Pakistan Find the best prices for Women s camisole in Pakistan Deck yourself with our dazzling collection of women s camisole Find the best quality camisole top in Pakistan with home delivery available across the Nation.
                  1. Andy 16 march 2023, 13:16 # 0
                    Brigade El Dorado is a luxurious residential project located in the serene and tranquil surroundings of North Bangalore, in the rapidly growing suburb of Bagalur.
                    1. Chinyere 17 march 2023, 08:58 # 0
                      Chinyere offers their customers an amazing range of Pakistani casual shirts. Get tops for women in Pakistan today. Only the best casual tops for girls online are available from Chinyere. Chinyere brings only the best casual dresses for their customers, always reaching for high standards.
                      1. کلاه کاسکت 31 march 2023, 14:45 # 0
                        Best motorcycle helmet shop
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت

                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت

                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        کلاه کاسکت
                        1. seofrisbee 04 april 2023, 16:55 # 0
                          The connection gives by and large Web frame update affiliations, including clarification research, SEO Service in Delhi content streamlining, outside interface establishment, and online redirection progress, and that is just the beginning.
                          1. seo 21 april 2023, 22:41 # 0
                            Are any of you interested in printing services? Check https://www.digitekprinting.com/vinyl-banners website out to see how affordable their prices are. The materials that they use are also environmentally friendly. Go visit their site now.
                            1. Batool Shaikh 26 april 2023, 15:09 # 0
                              I high appreciate this post. It’s hard to find the good from the bad sometimes, but I think you’ve nailed it! would you mind updating your blog with more information? disney clogs shoes
                              1. seo 28 april 2023, 22:50 # 0
                                Please share more like that. jordan matching shirts
                                1. Moola 02 may 2023, 10:30 # 0
                                  Asus is a popular brand of networking equipment, including routers. If you need assistance with your Asus router or encounter any issues with it, there are various support options available to help you troubleshoot and resolve the problem.

                                  Asus offers a support website where you can find resources such as product manuals, FAQs, and troubleshooting guides. They also have community forums where you can connect with other Asus users and get help from experts. Additionally, Asus provides contact options such as phone and email support for more personalized assistance.

                                  To configure your Asus router, you need to access its web interface by entering the router's IP address into a web browser and logging in with your credentials. From there, you can customize the router's settings, including the network name and password, security settings, and more.

                                  If you're experiencing problems with your Asus router, there are various troubleshooting steps you can take, such as resetting the router or checking for firmware updates. If the problem persists, you can contact Asus support for further assistance.

                                  Overall, Asus offers a range of support options to help you configure and troubleshoot your router, ensuring a positive user experience.
                                  For More Information visit us:-https://www.callroutersupport.com/asus-router-support/

                                  1. Moola 02 may 2023, 10:30 # 0
                                    Asus is a popular brand of networking equipment, including routers. If you need assistance with your Asus router or encounter any issues with it, there are various support options available to help you troubleshoot and resolve the problem.

                                    Asus offers a support website where you can find resources such as product manuals, FAQs, and troubleshooting guides. They also have community forums where you can connect with other Asus users and get help from experts. Additionally, Asus provides contact options such as phone and email support for more personalized assistance.

                                    To configure your Asus router, you need to access its web interface by entering the router's IP address into a web browser and logging in with your credentials. From there, you can customize the router's settings, including the network name and password, security settings, and more.

                                    If you're experiencing problems with your Asus router, there are various troubleshooting steps you can take, such as resetting the router or checking for firmware updates. If the problem persists, you can contact Asus support for further assistance.

                                    Overall, Asus offers a range of support options to help you configure and troubleshoot your router, ensuring a positive user experience.
                                    For More Information visit us:-
                                    www.callroutersupport.com/asus-router-support/
                                  2. Moola 02 may 2023, 10:32 # 0
                                    Carbonite is a popular cloud backup and recovery service that provides data protection for businesses and individuals. If you need assistance with your Carbonite product or encounter any issues with it, there are various support options available to help you troubleshoot and resolve the problem.

                                    Carbonite offers a support website where you can find resources such as product manuals, FAQs, and troubleshooting guides. They also have community forums where you can connect with other Carbonite users and get help from experts. Additionally, Carbonite provides contact options such as phone and email support for more personalized assistance.

                                    If you're experiencing problems with your Carbonite service, such as backup failures or restore issues, there are various troubleshooting steps you can take, such as checking your internet connection or reviewing the backup settings. If the problem persists, you can contact Carbonite support for further assistance.

                                    Overall, Carbonite offers a range of support options to help you protect and recover your data, ensuring a positive user experience.
                                    For More information visit us:-
                                    www.callsupportgroup.com/carbonite-support/
                                    1. Batool Shaikh 06 may 2023, 14:57 # 0
                                      This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. Is a prestige pressure cooker worth buying
                                      1. naveed 11 may 2023, 15:03 # 0
                                        Great! It sounds good. Thanks for sharing… piebald ball python for sale
                                        1. Naveedmughal 12 may 2023, 19:59 # 0
                                          Great post I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this interesting and knowledgeable article. nevada registered agents
                                          1. Naveedmughal 14 may 2023, 08:21 # 0
                                            Thanks for the post and great tips..even I also think that hard work is the most important aspect of getting success… registered agent new york
                                            1. Batool Shaikh 19 may 2023, 08:50 # 0
                                              i read a lot of stuff and i found that the way of writing to clearifing that exactly want to say was very good so i am impressed and ilike to come again in future… busch light shirt
                                              1. Game Guardian app 20 may 2023, 10:51 # 0
                                                Super, thank you for writing this blog. It is really helpful for me. Do you know what is the Game Guardian App? The Game Guardian app is a popular Android application that allows users to modify the values of games and applications. you can get the Game Guardian App on ios as well.
                                                1. Batool Shaikh 20 may 2023, 13:38 # 0
                                                  This is very educational content and written well for a change. It's nice to see that some people still understand how to write a quality post! straw backpack
                                                  1. Master Royale Private server 20 may 2023, 15:11 # 0
                                                    Thank you so much for sharing this great post. If you want to play Clash Royale as often as like without running out of gems, cash, or elixir. So you can play using Master Royale private server and enjoy unlimited fun. Go to the article for more details and get more information about Master Royale Private Server
                                                    1. Nimra shaikh 25 may 2023, 12:19 # 0
                                                      i read a lot of stuff and i found that the way of writing to clearifing that exactly want to say was very good so i am impressed and ilike to come again in future… situs porno
                                                      1. Batool Shaikh 28 may 2023, 07:48 # 0
                                                        Thank you again for all the knowledge you distribute,Good post. I was very interested in the article, it's quite inspiring I should admit. I like visiting you site since I always come across interesting articles like this one.Great Job, I greatly appreciate that.Do Keep sharing! Regards, film porno
                                                        1. Batool Shaikh 28 may 2023, 13:34 # 0
                                                          thanks for this usefull article, waiting for this article like this again. situs bokep
                                                          1. Aspire Bedding 29 may 2023, 16:13 # 0
                                                            Aspire Bedding is the best bed sheet brand in Pakistan because of its high-quality materials and affordable prices.
                                                            1. Naveedmughal 29 may 2023, 19:18 # 0
                                                              Thanks for sharing the info, keep up the good work going… I really enjoyed exploring your site. good resource… link bokep
                                                              1. Mannat Clothing 30 may 2023, 15:04 # 0
                                                                Don't miss out on the incredible Pakistani brands sale at Mannat Clothing. Indulge in the finest fashion offerings as they showcase their exquisite collection, blending traditional charm with contemporary style, all at irresistible prices.
                                                                1. Panache Apparel 30 may 2023, 16:20 # 0
                                                                  Experience the thrill of an online sale on brands at Panache Apparel. From the comfort of your home, explore a wide selection of premium fashion labels at discounted prices.
                                                                  1. Qhaaf Bedding 30 may 2023, 20:54 # 0
                                                                    Transform your bedroom into a cozy haven with Qhaaf Bedding's comforter sets Pakistan. Immerse yourself in ultimate comfort and style with their luxurious designs. Find the perfect set to enhance your sleep experience at Qhaaf.
                                                                    1. Batool Shaikh 31 may 2023, 23:22 # 0
                                                                      I can see that you are an expert at your field! I am launching a website soon, and your information will be very useful for me… Thanks for all your help and wishing you all the success in your business. film porno
                                                                      1. asim 02 june 2023, 13:29 # 0
                                                                        Wow i'll declare that that's just one more excellent report unsurprisingly of the blog.Bookmarked that site… Instanslot
                                                                        1. shaikhseo 02 june 2023, 16:19 # 0
                                                                          thanks for this usefull article, waiting for this article like this again. truco online
                                                                          1. shaikhseo 03 june 2023, 08:06 # 0
                                                                            New web site is seeking good. Thanks for the great effort. pharmacy service Canada
                                                                            1. okbet 03 june 2023, 09:01 # 0
                                                                              There's no doubt i would fully rate it after i read what is the idea about this article. You did a nice job.
                                                                              okbet
                                                                              1. asim Yesterday at 08:22 # 0
                                                                                This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging. Looking to reading your next post. Garden Sheds for Sale Auckland
                                                                                1. shaikhseo Yesterday at 10:27 # 0
                                                                                  This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging. Looking to reading your next post. Garden Sheds for Sale Christchurch