The EU’s existential crisis, averted with compromise, for today

Michael Emerson

Op-ed No. 15/2020

Since my contribution to the paper on 8 April ended with the EU facing a huge existential choice, to be resolved the following day, we should update the story.


On 9 April a compromise was reached, as usual, as many Brussels old-timers would say. Finance ministers agreed on three measures mobilising €540 billion or about 3.6% of GDP:


  • The European Stability Mechanism is to be activated for Eurozone countries up to the €240 billion, but borrowers will not face the usual macroeconomic policy conditionality, only the requirement to use the funds for countering Covid-19 damage to the economy and society. 


  • There will be €200 billion increased loan guarantees from the European Investment Bank to support small and medium-sized enterprises.


  • There will be a new and temporary instrument, called ‘SURE’, under which the European Commission would raise loans of up to €100 billion, to be made available to member states which need support for their labour market measures, including short-time work and unemployment benefits.


  • In addition there is agreement to work up a new Recovery Fund.


These new decisions are on top of fiscal measures by member states amounting to 3% of EU GDP, and additional monetary liquidity measures amounting to 16% of GDP.   


So the amounts are massive, with more to come. Where does this leave the EU, given the high tensions surrounding the negotiations? 


The biggest issue of discord was the request from Italy, supported by Spain and with some nuance France, for something in the category of ‘Eurobonds’ or ‘Coronabonds’ to bring massive help the most needy member states without increasing their public debt, which is already very high in the case of Italy and Greece.  The point of this proposition is that the borrower should be the EU, who would thus be responsible for servicing the debt, not the individual member states. ‘Mutualisation’ of the debt is the key word to represent this option. 


This was contested by mostly northern member states, and most vociferously the Netherlands, who have made strong objections to anything that would result in transfers of financial grants, or aid that was not subject to conditions.  Germany has adopted this same position in the past, but Angela Merkel’s recent speeches have hinted at some possible flexibility, with emphasis on the historic strategic responsibility that the EU come together to overcome the crisis. 


The Dutch position was to insist both on use of the European Stability Mechanism for funding the most needy states, meaning that the beneficiary state and not the EU would be the borrower, and that such funding would be subject to conditions to avoid creating a ‘moral hazard’ for potential borrowers. The use of this term in the present Covid-19 context is generally repudiated in public opinion as being irrelevant – to put it lightly. 


The compromise outcome was thus that while the European Stability Mechanism would be used, not the Eurobond or Coronabonds, the only condition would be that the funds be used to support public health and pandemic-related social policies. In addition the European Commission and European Investment Bank  would undertake large scale borrowing or loan guarantee operation, and these operations mean that with the EU as borrower there is a degree of effective ‘mutualisation’.


So this is the compromise for the time being. The existential crisis is averted. But the story is far from finished. The overwhelming majority of academic economists and independent policy analysts in think tanks advocate more radical measures to assure the systemic sustainability of the EU. The mechanisms for this would come from the experience of various federations, and would see indeed mutualisation of large scale borrowing by the EU to fund measures to compensate for the deep recession that Covid-19 is imposing, such as unemployment or income maintenance programmes, or support for small and medium sized enterprises. These would be classic mechanisms of economic policy, but there is also a big political calculus at stake, notably what needs to be done to avoid a deepening estrangement toward the EU on the part of Italian public opinion.    


As the lockdown continues, homeworking and video-conferencing reach a point that many commentators see now a permanent structural change to the global economy. Of course many will go back to the office or factory, but many will install themselves at home as their permanent work place. And much flying for business meetings and long-range touristic flying will be gone forever. Already Co2 emissions in urban centres have fallen drastically, maybe bringing climate policy objectives into sight of achievement. Could this become the big collateral impact of Covid-19? A global pandemic, threatening something on the scale of a medieval plague, was needed to save the planet from the irresponsibility of humankind’s behaviour over the last century. Have some Greek gods been at work? 

The adjusted Ukrainian version of the op-ed was originally published in “European Pravda” (April 14, 2020).


Comments ()

  1. Karan Wilkes 11 august 2023, 07:12 # 0
    These are standard economic policy tools, but there are also important political calculations to be made, such as what needs to be done to keep Italian public opinion from becoming even more hostile toward the EU. free games
    1. Adoro 04 october 2023, 11:52 # 0
      Our online store presents a beautiful selection of stylish bags for women. We have a variety of high-quality choices that suit every taste, ranging from fashionable handbags to mini bagspurses and stylish clutches. Find the ideal bag for improving your style by shopping right away.
        1. Mohagni 05 october 2023, 10:26 # 0
          Mohagni provides an extensive selection of Chiffon Dress design, available in various colors and styles that are perfect for every occasion. Visit Mohagni’s website to explore their diverse collection of chiffon dresses and order your preferred dress online today.
          1. Chahyay 05 october 2023, 10:48 # 0
            Find the perfect Luxury Pret at Chahyay. Browse our collection and get the best Quality Pret dresses that will make you shine at any event. Shop now.
            1. Shahtaj Qaiser 05 october 2023, 14:36 # 0
              Shop for the latest semi formal dresses Pakistani by Shahtaj Qaiser. We have gained immense popularity worldwide for semi formal dresses. We offer various fabrics such as cotton, silk, net, and chiffon in different styles, colors, and designs. Buy your favorite dress online today!
              1. Borjan 05 october 2023, 15:27 # 0
                Borjan presents the best collection of formal shoes for men online in Pakistan. Explore the variety of men's formal shoes online at Borjan. Grab your favorite shoes online at affordable prices today.
                1. Raffat 06 october 2023, 10:48 # 0
                  Looking for a Marriage Lawyer in Rawalpindi? Our skilled legal experts are dedicated to facilitating seamless court marriage proceedings.
                  1. nanipk 11 october 2023, 11:11 # 0
                    Find the right baby cot bed for a peaceful night's sleep for your child. Our selection offers comfort, protection, and fashion. Shop right away to take great care of your child.
                    1. Kafas Tourism 12 october 2023, 18:21 # 0
                      Discover the essence of uae cities with KafasTourism. Our expert guides will lead you through the dynamic urban landscapes, providing insights into the unique blend of tradition and innovation that defines this remarkable country.
                      1. Jewel Galore 12 october 2023, 20:52 # 0
                        Jewelgalore presents a striking collection of silver ring for men . Explore our range of elegantly crafted pieces, perfect for adding sophistication and style to men's fashion.
                        1. Shalamar Hospital 16 october 2023, 15:34 # 0
                          Shalamar Hospital is your trusted healthcare destination, offering the expertise of a renowned stomach specialist . Expect top-notch care for gastrointestinal health.
                          1. Gloria Carlo 17 october 2023, 07:55 # 0
                            Wonderful site. Plenty of helpful information here. Tired of those annoying Twitch ads but don't know how to get rid of them? Look no further; Twitch Adblocker is here to help you block Twitch ads.
                            1. Esmiranda Joye 17 october 2023, 11:34(Comment was edited) # 0
                              In contrast to the current legal structure, under which drift boss individuals holding the nationality of a Member State are automatically granted Union citizenship, individuals under this plan would be allowed to choose whether or not to assume the status of citizen of an emerging European polity.
                              1. Kafas Tourism 17 october 2023, 14:04 # 0
                                Kafas Tourism's Dubai City Tour with Dubai Frame is your ticket to explore the city's wonders. Discover the fusion of tradition and modernity in this iconic metropolis.
                                1. uweissna 18 october 2023, 06:45 # 0
                                  These are common economic policy instruments, but there are also crucial political calculations to be made, such as how to prevent an even more negative public perception of the EU in Italy. basketball stars
                                  1. Jewel Galore 28 october 2023, 12:28 # 0
                                    Jewelgalore features a captivating collection of couple rings , perfect for expressing your love and commitment. Explore our beautifully crafted pieces, symbolizing unity and shared moments.
                                    1. Kafas Tourism 30 october 2023, 10:53 # 0
                                      Discover the allure of the Dubai desert without breaking the bank with KafasTourism's affordable desert safari dubai cost. We offer thrilling experiences at budget-friendly rates.
                                      1. alyssa lauren 31 october 2023, 11:15 # 0
                                        As a political analyst, the EU's resolution to its existential crisis through compromise showcases the bloc's adaptability. However, sustaining this compromise demands ongoing collaboration, addressing Lab grown diamonds structural issues, and unifying diverse member state interests. Achieving long-term stability and reinforcing EU unity necessitates consistent diplomatic efforts and proactive policy adjustments.
                                        1. OSH UNIVERSITY 10 november 2023, 15:25 # 0
                                          Osh University stands as the epitome of excellence, acclaimed as the best university for MBBS in world . Immerse yourself in a transformative learning environment where cutting-edge education meets a commitment to shaping the future leaders of medicine.
                                          1. muneer ahmed 14 november 2023, 14:21 # 0
                                            This is my first time visit to your blog and I am very interested in the articles that you serve. Provide enough knowledge for me. SaaS Contract Lawyer Thank you for sharing useful and don't forget, keep sharing useful info:
                                            1. muneer ahmed 15 november 2023, 09:05 # 0
                                              Great job for publishing such a beneficial web site. Your web log isn’t only useful but it is additionally really creative too. wiet online There tend to be not many people who can certainly write not so simple posts that artistically. Continue the nice writing
                                              1. Rental Sport 15 november 2023, 10:37 # 0
                                                Elevate your active lifestyle with Rental Sport's premium sport clothing . Designed for enthusiasts and athletes alike, our high-quality collection blends performance and style, ensuring you stand out on and off the field.
                                                1. Rental Sport 15 november 2023, 13:13 # 0
                                                  Unleash your sporty spirit at Rental Sport's sports clothing stores . From performance wear to casual essentials, find the perfect fit for your active lifestyle. Elevate your wardrobe with quality rentals that make a statement on and off the field.
                                                  1. muneer ahmed 15 november 2023, 14:01 # 0
                                                    Thanks a lot for sharing us about this update. SaaS Contract Attorney Hope you will not get tired on making posts as informative as this.
                                                    1. jewelgalore 16 november 2023, 11:56 # 0
                                                      Jewel Galore is where dreams come to life with our exquisite wedding rings . Crafted with precision and love, our collection ensures your special day is celebrated with the perfect symbol of your eternal commitment.
                                                      1. Jones elizebeth 16 november 2023, 13:53 # 0
                                                        This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing blog that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free. msg sphere led screen
                                                        1. Rental Sport 21 november 2023, 11:01 # 0
                                                          Elevate your casual wardrobe with Rental Sport's Formula 1 shirt . Immerse yourself in top-tier gear crafted for comfort and style, ensuring you showcase your passion for Formula 1 in every detail.
                                                          1. Shalamar Hospital 21 november 2023, 11:01 # 0
                                                            Looking for expert gastrointestinal care? Shalamar Hospital's stomach doctor offers top-notch treatments and consultations, prioritizing your stomach's well-being.
                                                            1. brownieslapis 25 december 2023, 04:59 # 0
                                                              This is my inaugural visit to your blog, and I am really intrigued by the material that you provide. Please furnish me with a sufficient amount of information basketball stars
                                                              1. Rufus Bowman 12 january 2024, 12:47 # 0
                                                                Great info! I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to say except that I have. Cinnamon Powder
                                                                1. Randy Butler 22 january 2024, 20:06 # 0
                                                                  So it is interesting and very good written and see what they think about other people. spookyswap
                                                                  1. Andree Oren 30 january 2024, 11:24 # 0
                                                                    The only thing I've successfully merged in Watermelon Game is my confusion and excitement. It's a fruit salad of emotions.
                                                                    1. Sanahan12 02 april 2024, 13:09 # 0
                                                                      This is no ordinary waffle. waffle game is a highly entertaining game for all players who love word guessing games. You can play with any time. The game is unlimited so you can play multiple times a day without worry.
                                                                      1. emmajessica 16 may 2024, 07:15 # 0
                                                                        The crisis also has an end. grade calculator