And now Kazakhstan... in the wider European competition of democracy vs autocracy

Michael Emerson

Op-ed No. 1/2022

Kazakhstan is Central Asia rather than Europe, but Putin has made it part of the European political equation by instrumentalising it as a key element of the Eurasian Economic Union, intended to counter the expansion of European Union’s membership or influence in European states of the former Soviet Union. 

 

On 2 January 2022, in western Kazakhstan in the city of Zhanaozen, demonstrations erupted, protesting the rise in fuel prices. By 5 January the uprising had spread across the country, with major violence in the country’s largest city, Almaty, where the airport was seized by rioters and the buildings of the mayor and presidency damaged. President Tokayev rescinded the fuel price rises, and declared a national emergency, informing security personal to shoot to kill without warning. By 9 January the interior ministry stated that 6,000 protestors has been arrested, 194 killed, with 18 security personnel also killed. President Tokayev stated the protests were the work of terrorist foreign agents, for which there is no evidence at all according to Western journalists on the spot, while Russian state television has characteristically broadcast disinformation on this, implying that thousands of jihadis were driving the process.  

 

The timing could not have been worse for Putin, since it comes coincidentally as he mounts pressure on the West to shape the European security order to his taste, while his two direct neighbors and allies on his western and eastern flanks both show themselves to be disordered and failing political regimes.  While Putin’s big security gambit remains to be played out, the political map and dynamics of the wider Europe become clearer. While Putin claims to be surrounded by NATO threats, the first ring of threats to his authoritarian regime comes from the Eurasian Economic Union states themselves. 

 

In 2018 Armenia took a democratic turn with Pashinyan’s successful uprising, to Moscow’s evident displeasure. 

 

Much more serious was the uprising in 2020 in Belarus, which came close to a democratic colour revolution to unseat Lukashenko. The sequel has underlined a first principle of the dynamics of authoritarian regimes: to be sustained they have to become increasingly repressive, until at some point they implode.

 

Kazakhstan fits into this model. For most of the time under Nazabayev it was a quiet authoritarian state. The regime has now become increasingly repressive and reliant on external support to survive. Tokayev was so desperate that he requested and immediately received military support from the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), triggered by invocation of its clause equivalent to NATO’s article V. Troops have been sent in by Russia, Armenia, Belarus, Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan. These security guarantees are meant to be about external threats.

 

The model is further at play in Russia itself, as illustrated on 28 December 2021 by the Supreme Court’s closure of Memorial on the bogus grounds that it had refused to register as a ‘foreign agent’, following the attempted assassination of Navalny in 2020 and his imprisonment in 2021.

 

On a further detail, Kyrgyzstan has a long track record as Central Asia’s least undemocratic state, with President Jeenbekov elected in 2019 with a mandate to parliamentary democracy. 

 

As to Europe’s other authoritarian leaders, Erdogan’s regime in Turkey seems to be moving towards its end, partly due to his exotically incompetent monetary policy, already causing collapse of the currency. Meanwhile, Aliev in Azerbaijan seems to be living off the bonus of a successful war with Armenia, relying on one of the last resorts of the autocrat – a patriotic military victory.  

 

By comparison, the ongoing debates about democracy’s failings or imperfections in the rest of Europe find their fundamental perspectives. Democratic processes in core Western Europe appear to be quite robust, with populist challenges losing ground, for example in Italy. In the UK Johnson is a populist leader who has become unpopular. His time will be up soon. But his Brexit, while terribly damaging for the UK itself, has at least enabled the EU to advance impressively through its COVID recovery programme without being hobbled by a London veto over its funding. 

 

The most seriously defective European democracies in Central and Eastern Europe are struggling rather than collapsing. In both Hungary and Poland serious political opposition parties exist and will challenge the incumbents in forthcoming elections. Bulgaria has just voted in more correctly democratic leadership. 

 

Last but not least come the Trio states of Eastern Europe –  Ukraine, Moldova and Georgia – who are democratic Europe’s frontline against the repressive and aggressive Russia. Zelensky’s leadership in Ukraine is weak and flawed, but the country is still an open democracy with a vibrant civil society. Moldova became in 2020-21 a model of how a deeply defective democracy can still have the capacity and flexibility to engineer democratic renewal and serious political reform. A model also for Georgia’s currently increasingly undemocratic regime to emulate in due course.  

 

The overall conclusion, reduced to basics, seems to be that Europe’s autocracies are failing regimes, while Europe’s democracies are either robust or plausible candidates for improvement. While Putin threatens Europe with hypersonic missiles, his position in the underlying balance of competing political ideologies is weak, at least in the European continent. Maybe the Russian people will sometime conclude that their state should offer them other public goods than an outsized military. 

 

Comments ()

  1. SEO 01 march 2023, 18:02 # 0
    Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. Flights in pakistan
    1. Batool Shaikh 04 may 2023, 10:05 # 0
      Thank you again for all the knowledge you distribute,Good post. I was very interested in the article, it's quite inspiring I should admit. I like visiting you site since I always come across interesting articles like this one.Great Job, I greatly appreciate that.Do Keep sharing! Regards, connecticut.butcherblockcountertop.net
      1. Batool Shaikh 04 may 2023, 12:48 # 0
        Love to read it,Waiting For More new Update and I Already Read your Recent Post its Great Thanks. north-dakota.butcherblockcountertop.net
        1. Batool Shaikh 04 may 2023, 15:06 # 0
          That is really nice to hear. thank you for the update and good luck. arkansas.butcherblockcountertop.net
          1. naveed 05 may 2023, 10:27 # 0
            This is my first time i visit here. I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment here! keep up the good work connecticut.butcherblockcountertop.org
            1. naveed 05 may 2023, 11:28 # 0
              Thank you very much for this useful article. I like it. north-dakota.butcherblockcountertop.org
              1. naveed 05 may 2023, 13:21 # 0
                Great article Lot's of information to Read...Great Man Keep Posting and update to People..Thanks virginia.butcherblockcountertop.org
                1. naveed 06 may 2023, 22:53 # 0
                  Nice Informative Blog having nice sharing… connecticut.butcherblockcountertops.cc
                  1. naveed 06 may 2023, 23:49 # 0
                    thanks this is good blog. north-dakota.butcherblockcountertops.cc
                    1. naveed 07 may 2023, 00:49 # 0
                      Wow i can say that this is another great article as expected of this blog.Bookmarked this site… virginia.butcherblockcountertops.cc
                      1. naveed 07 may 2023, 12:17 # 0
                        This is my first time i visit here. I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment here! keep up the good work connecticut.complexkitchens.com
                        1. naveed 07 may 2023, 13:22 # 0
                          Thanks for the valuable information and insights you have so provided here… north-dakota.complexkitchens.com
                          1. naveed 07 may 2023, 14:26 # 0
                            That is really nice to hear. thank you for the update and good luck. virginia.complexkitchens.com
                            1. Batool Shaikh 09 may 2023, 13:37 # 0
                              I appreciated your work very thanks k2 spice
                              1. Nimra 20 may 2023, 18:11 # 0
                                i love reading this article so beautiful!!great job! Agencia de Modelos
                                1. Mushtaq Clothing 21 may 2023, 14:09 # 0
                                  Find the perfect dress for any occasion with the latest collection of Maria B dresses, available exclusively at Mushtaq. Discover premium quality, stylish options, and unbeatable prices. Shop now and elevate your wardrobe with these must-have dresses.
                                  1. Batool Shaikh 23 may 2023, 13:50 # 0
                                    Thanks for your information, it was really very helpfull… Fuentes de Ingreso
                                    1. Naveedmughal 24 may 2023, 08:36 # 0
                                      Thanks For sharing this Superb article.I use this Article to show my assignment in college.it is useful For me Great Work.Detergentes baratos
                                      1. Naveedmughal 25 may 2023, 00:59 # 0
                                        Great article Lot's of information to Read...Great Man Keep Posting and update to People..Thanks Digital Marketing
                                        1. Naveedmughal 25 may 2023, 01:51 # 0
                                          thanks for this usefull article, waiting for this article like this again. Search Engine Optimization
                                          1. Naveedmughal 27 may 2023, 08:56 # 0
                                            Great article Lot's of information to Read...Great Man Keep Posting and update to People..Thanks hog roast hire
                                            1. Naveedmughal 27 may 2023, 09:39 # 0
                                              Thanks for your information, it was really very helpfull… hog roast near me
                                              1. Naveedmughal 27 may 2023, 13:41 # 0
                                                Thanks for a wonderful share. Your article has proved your hard work and experience you have got in this field. Brilliant .i love it reading. alabama.butcherblockcountertop.net
                                                1. Naveedmughal 27 may 2023, 15:35 # 0
                                                  Thanks for your information, it was really very helpfull… indiana.butcherblockcountertop.net
                                                  1. Naveedmughal 28 may 2023, 07:15 # 0
                                                    Love to read it,Waiting For More new Update and I Already Read your Recent Post its Great Thanks. north-carolina.butcherblockcountertop.net
                                                    1. Naveedmughal 28 may 2023, 09:04 # 0
                                                      Thanks For sharing this Superb article.I use this Article to show my assignment in college.it is useful For me Great Work. south-carolina.butcherblockcountertop.net
                                                      1. Naveedmughal 29 may 2023, 11:19 # 0
                                                        This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. Terapia de Pareja Malaga
                                                        1. shaikhseo 01 june 2023, 21:43 # 0
                                                          Most of the time I don’t make comments on websites, but I'd like to say that this article really forced me to do so. Really nice post! scrap car removal Burnaby
                                                          1. okbet 03 june 2023, 09:12 # 0
                                                            Quality posts is the crucial to invite the visitors to visit the web page, that's what this web page is providing.
                                                            okbet online casino
                                                            1. Naveedmughal 03 june 2023, 22:22 # 0
                                                              Thanks for the valuable information and insights you have so provided here… Grand Dunman condo
                                                              1. Naveedmughal 07 june 2023, 12:00 # 0
                                                                Thanks for the post and great tips..even I also think that hard work is the most important aspect of getting success… bounce house rentals Sarasota
                                                                1. Naveedmughal 07 june 2023, 14:03 # 0
                                                                  I found your this post while searching for some related information on blog search...Its a good post..keep posting and update the information. alabama.butcherblockcountertops.cc
                                                                  1. Batool Shaikh 07 june 2023, 14:54 # 0
                                                                    I appreciated your work very thanks alabama.butcherblockcountertop.org
                                                                    1. Naveedmughal 07 june 2023, 20:40 # 0
                                                                      Thanks for a wonderful share. Your article has proved your hard work and experience you have got in this field. Brilliant .i love it reading. kentucky.butcherblockcountertops.cc
                                                                      1. Naveedmughal 07 june 2023, 21:56 # 0
                                                                        Thanks For sharing this Superb article.I use this Article to show my assignment in college.it is useful For me Great Work. new-mexico.butcherblockcountertops.cc
                                                                        1. Naveedmughal 07 june 2023, 23:04 # 0
                                                                          Thanks For sharing this Superb article.I use this Article to show my assignment in college.it is useful For me Great Work. washington.butcherblockcountertops.cc
                                                                          1. Naveedmughal Yesterday at 09:29 # 0
                                                                            That is really nice to hear. thank you for the update and good luck. Click the Following Webpage
                                                                            1. shaikhseo Yesterday at 10:22 # 0
                                                                              Most of the time I don’t make comments on websites, but I'd like to say that this article really forced me to do so. Really nice post! Click the Following Webpage
                                                                              1. Batool Shaikh Yesterday at 11:10 # 0
                                                                                i read a lot of stuff and i found that the way of writing to clearifing that exactly want to say was very good so i am impressed and ilike to come again in future… Click the Following Webpage
                                                                                1. Naveedmughal Yesterday at 12:19 # 0
                                                                                  i love reading this article so beautiful!!great job! Click Here For More Info
                                                                                  1. Naveedmughal Yesterday at 13:44 # 0
                                                                                    Thanks for sharing the info, keep up the good work going… I really enjoyed exploring your site. good resource… Read This Page
                                                                                    1. Mike Rooney Yesterday at 13:53 # 0
                                                                                      I found this post very exciting. I am also sending it to my friends to enjoy this blog.
                                                                                      Edgerunner Jacket

                                                                                      1. Batool Shaikh Yesterday at 15:02 # 0
                                                                                        Yes i am totally agreed with this article and i just want say that this article is very nice and very informative article.I will make sure to be reading your blog more. You made a good point but I can't help but wonder, what about the other side? !!!!!!THANKS!!! Click Through the Following Webpage
                                                                                        1. Naveedmughal Yesterday at 16:43 # 0
                                                                                          i read a lot of stuff and i found that the way of writing to clearifing that exactly want to say was very good so i am impressed and ilike to come again in future… See More Hints
                                                                                          1. Batool Shaikh Yesterday at 17:04 # 0
                                                                                            Please share more like that. Check Out This Info
                                                                                            1. shaikhseo Yesterday at 17:37 # 0
                                                                                              Yes i am totally agreed with this article and i just want say that this article is very nice and very informative article.I will make sure to be reading your blog more. You made a good point but I can't help but wonder, what about the other side? !!!!!!THANKS!!! Visit This URL
                                                                                              1. shaikhseo Yesterday at 18:37 # 0
                                                                                                That is really nice to hear. thank you for the update and good luck. Learn more
                                                                                                1. Batool Shaikh Yesterday at 19:35 # 0
                                                                                                  I appreciated your work very thanks Visit This Webpage
                                                                                                  1. Naveedmughal Yesterday at 19:58 # 0
                                                                                                    I appreciated your work very thanks Refer to This Site for Additional Information
                                                                                                    1. Naveedmughal 3 hours ago # 0
                                                                                                      Thank you again for all the knowledge you distribute,Good post. I was very interested in the article, it's quite inspiring I should admit. I like visiting you site since I always come across interesting articles like this one.Great Job, I greatly appreciate that.Do Keep sharing! Regards, More information
                                                                                                      1. shaikhseo 2 hours ago # 0
                                                                                                        Most of the time I don’t make comments on websites, but I'd like to say that this article really forced me to do so. Really nice post! Click the Following Internet Site
                                                                                                        1. Naveedmughal 21 minutes ago # 0
                                                                                                          Thanks for the valuable information and insights you have so provided here… Click the Following Internet Site