Results of Ukraine's 2015 Wood Moratorium: Trade Protectionism vs Forest Protection

Yevhen Anhel

Op-ed No. 7/2021

In December 2020, the Arbitration Panel presented its ruling on the Ukrainian ban on exports of all unprocessed wood. More than five years after its adoption, Ukraine's wood export moratorium was found incompatible with the Association Agreement (AA) and not justified under the GATT 1994. Ukraine's arguments were weak to prove that conservation of forests was the moratorium's primary goal.

 

Ukraine's parliament introduced the 10-year moratorium on round wood exports in 2015. It became partially effective (for species other than pine) from November 1, 2015, and fully effective (including pine) from January 1, 2017. Since the very beginning, the EU emphasized that export restrictions contradicted the AA. Abolition of the moratorium even became one of the conditions for receiving EU macro-financial assistance. However, EU-Ukraine discussions and consultations did not result in lifting the export ban. In June 2019, the EU requested the establishment of an arbitration panel.

 

Ukraine based its defence on the claim that forests are the "national treasure" and have to be preserved.  The ratio of forest to the total area puts Ukraine only in the 34th place in Europe, and the forest cover is lower than recommended for the country (15.9% vs 20%). In 2018, the Verkhovna Rada also set the limit of domestic wood consumption at 25 million cubic meters and criminalized round wood smuggling to justify the moratorium. However, environmental objectives have not been genuinely included in the moratorium's design. As a result, the EU argued that the guise of environmental measures just shielded domestic industry, and the export ban allowed a "high and unprecedented level of domestic consumption" in Ukraine. 

 

Figure 1. Logging of round wood (2010-2019), million cubic meters

 

Source: State Statistics Service of Ukraine

 

Official statistics show that export restrictions do not have a direct impact on logging. In 2013-2019, the volume of logged wood had remained circa 18-20 million cubic meters (see Figure 1). It is much lower than the limit on domestic consumption established by the parliament. 

 

Ukrainian politicians also argued that the moratorium should fight illicit logging, but its volume is unknown. Official statistics contain numbers regarding only revealed cases (118 thousand cubic meters in 2019), but the real volume might be dozens of times higher. As a result, there is no evidence of the moratorium's impact on logging (both legal and illegal).

 

Many Ukrainian experts agreed that the restrictions were more helpful for Ukraine's manufacturers than for forest protection. Initially, domestic industry support was defined as the moratorium law's principal objective, based on its explanatory note. Export ban undoubtedly boosted wood processing, primarily the sawmill industry expansion (more than +50% cumulatively in 2014-2020). As a result, wood processing was one of the few industrial sectors that grew compared to 2013. The export ban also stimulated the development of unregistered small sawmills. It was estimated that in 2017 there were about 21 thousand sawmills in Ukraine, of which 12 thousand were illegal. The numbers above support the argument that the sawing industry was the primary beneficiary of the moratorium.  

 

Figure 2. Indices of industrial production (2013-2019), per cent to the previous year

 

Source: State Statistics Service of Ukraine

 

Furniture manufacturing demonstrated more moderate growth than the sawing industry, cumulatively +16% in 2014-2020. Nevertheless, the moratorium on the sector is uncertain. Furniture manufacturers also had other incentives that could spur production. In particular, Ukrainian companies fulfilled domestic demand after imports decreased thrice in 2015-2017 due to devaluation. Almost half of the produced furniture is sold within Ukraine.

 

Figure 3. Exports of wood, wood products and furniture (2013-2020), USD million

 

 

Source: State Statistics Service of Ukraine

Note: The chart includes information on wooden furniture used in the office, kitchen, bedroom, and other kinds

 

Trade statistics mirror changes in production (see Figure 3). Exports of wood, wood products, and furniture in total increased by a third from 2015 to 2018, when its value reached its peak recently (USD 1.6 billion). 

 

Before the moratorium, round wood made about one-fifth of total exports of wood, wood products and wooden furniture (USD 254 million in 2014). The restrictions gradually reduced official exports of round wood almost to zero by 2017. Instead, exports of wood products, mostly sawn wood, expanded. In 2019, sawn wood made USD 515 million of exports, compared to circa USD 360 million in 2014-2015. Ukraine also almost doubled exports of veneer sheets and sheets for plywood and builders' joinery and wood carpentry. In 2017-2020, exports of wooden furniture tripled, reaching USD 210 million. 


To sum up, official statistics show that the wood moratorium of 2015 was primarily a protectionist measure. According to the Arbitrator Pane's ruling, now Ukraine must resolve the breach of its obligations under the AA. However, the moratorium's consequences are a good lesson for the government and parliament that the design of their decisions must be well considered before adoption.

Comments ()

  1. SEO 20 april 2023, 00:24 # 0
    Wow what a Great Information about World Day its very nice informative post. thanks for the post. no fault orthopaedic surgeon
    1. Batool Shaikh 20 april 2023, 12:17 # 0
      I have bookmarked your blog, the articles are way better than other similar blogs… thanks for a great blog! workers compensation doctor
      1. SEO 20 april 2023, 19:02 # 0
        Thank you for the update, very nice site… no fault orthopaedic doctor
        1. Batool Shaikh 21 april 2023, 02:30 # 0
          I really appreciate the kind of topics you post here. Thanks for sharing us a great information that is actually helpful. Good day! no fault orthopaedic doctor
          1. Batool Shaikh 27 april 2023, 00:16 # 0
            Thanks for sharing the info, keep up the good work going… I really enjoyed exploring your site. good resource… women disney crocs shoes
            1. SEO 28 april 2023, 23:19 # 0
              I am hoping the same best effort from you in the future as well. In fact your creative writing skills has inspired me. jordan matching shirts
              1. SEO 29 april 2023, 17:21 # 0
                Thank you truly much for the sharing! COOL. Vape Carts For Sale in Minnesota
                1. Bushra shaikh 30 april 2023, 15:46 # 0
                  Thanks for sharing the info, keep up the good work going… I really enjoyed exploring your site. good resource… transparent-merchant
                  1. Bushra shaikh 30 april 2023, 21:11 # 0
                    Great! It sounds good. Thanks for sharing… spiralteck
                    1. SEO 06 may 2023, 16:54 # 0
                      This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing websites that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free. It is the old what goes around comes around routine. What is Elica ductless chimney
                      1. Batool Shaikh 14 may 2023, 09:22 # 0
                        Thank you again for all the knowledge you distribute,Good post. I was very interested in the article, it's quite inspiring I should admit. I like visiting you site since I always come across interesting articles like this one.Great Job, I greatly appreciate that.Do Keep sharing! Regards, registered agent georgia
                        1. Batool Shaikh 15 may 2023, 15:19 # 0
                          Thank you for taking the time to publish this information very useful! new jersey registered agent
                          1. Batool Shaikh 16 may 2023, 15:36 # 0
                            I appreciated your work very thanks Koreansk hudpleje
                            1. Batool Shaikh 18 may 2023, 19:41 # 0
                              Wow i can say that this is another great article as expected of this blog.Bookmarked this site… bud light t shirt
                              1. Batool Shaikh 19 may 2023, 20:55 # 0
                                Thanks for the valuable information and insights you have so provided here… raffia crossbody
                                1. Mushtaq Clothing 21 may 2023, 13:01 # 0
                                  Mushtaq brings you the best new designer dresses online in Pakistan. Explore the variety of the latest designer dresses online and get your favorite dresses in all over Pakistan at affordable prices.
                                  1. Batool Shaikh 25 may 2023, 10:51 # 0
                                    Wow what a Great Information about World Day its very nice informative post. thanks for the post. bokep indo
                                    1. Batool Shaikh 28 may 2023, 03:56 # 0
                                      thanks for this usefull article, waiting for this article like this again. video porno
                                      1. Batool Shaikh 28 may 2023, 12:53 # 0
                                        Thanks for the valuable information and insights you have so provided here… situs porno
                                        1. Nimra shaikh 28 may 2023, 15:36 # 0
                                          i love reading this article so beautiful!!great job! situs bokep
                                          1. shaikh seo 29 may 2023, 15:59 # 0
                                            Thank you very much for this useful article. I like it. jokowi kontol
                                            1. Batool Shaikh 31 may 2023, 14:10 # 0
                                              This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging. Looking to reading your next post. link bokep
                                              1. shaikhseo 01 june 2023, 18:22 # 0
                                                Great! It sounds good. Thanks for sharing… soap2day euphoria
                                                1. asimseo 02 june 2023, 17:00 # 0
                                                  i love reading this article so beautiful!!great job! truco online
                                                  1. Batool Shaikh 03 june 2023, 08:24 # 0
                                                    Wow just what a Great Information regarding Earth Day its excellent informative post. thanks for the post. www.canadacloudpharmacy.com
                                                    1. shaikh seo 04 june 2023, 08:25 # 0
                                                      Thanks for the post and great tips..even I also think that hard work is the most important aspect of getting success… Garden Sheds Auckland
                                                      1. shaikh seo 04 june 2023, 17:47 # 0
                                                        Thanks for the post and great tips..even I also think that hard work is the most important aspect of getting success..Garden Sheds Christchurch
                                                        1. shaikhseo 05 june 2023, 10:10 # 0
                                                          Gynecomastia treatment with regional anesthesia, fast recovery and reduced prices....γυναικομαστια
                                                          1. shaikhseo 05 june 2023, 10:11 # 0
                                                            Gynecomastia treatment with regional anesthesia, fast recovery and reduced prices… γυναικομαστια
                                                            1. Batool Shaikh 05 june 2023, 11:15 # 0
                                                              Many thanks for the update, excellent site… kolkata ff patti
                                                              1. shaikhseo 06 june 2023, 16:54 # 0
                                                                Lego, Playmobil, Djeco and Wooden Online toys. Buy with confidence from our Online Shop or from our Shop in Aphrodite Hills, Paphos, Cyprus Djeco Online Toys Cyprus