The Advent of Biopolitics: Repercussion for the EU, Russia, and Eastern Partnership Countries

Andrey Makarychev

Op-ed No. 22/2020

The COVID-19 had significantly changed the structure of world politics by shifting its core from issues of geopolitics to what in the academic literature for quite some time has been known as global biopolitics. As a concept, biopolitics implies political strategies and calculations based on protecting human lives, taking care of people and managing public health, medicine and hygiene, and advancing the role of an apolitical civil society.


However, the global scope of the pandemic so far did not foster political consolidation among key international actors. On the contrary, the biopolitical momentum triggered more diversity and fragmentation in the world. Dynamics across the triangle EU–Russia–Eastern Partnership (EaP) states seem to be quite illustrative of this trend (as also looking with European binoculars across the Atlantic at the responses to the pandemic of Trump and Bolsonaro).

For the EU, the basic challenge has been how to integrate biopolitical priorities into its normative power framework. Of course, some steps in this direction were made before the eruption of the COVID-19 crisis: for example, the idea of responsibility to protect (R2P) to which the EU seems to be highly sympathetic was based on a strong biopolitical principle of saving human lives irrespective of identities or ethnic and other affiliations. Another example might be the idea of a “European way of life” that has recently entered EU’s political lexicon, with a broad range of biopolitical pointers – from saving lives of immigrants to securing consumer rights. However, the 2020 pandemic has unveiled the harshest biopolitical challenge in the EU’s history. 


The model policy response was provided by Angela Merkel, who led Germany’s outstanding performance of care and competence in limiting the ravages of the pandemic, and more exactly keeping the fatalities to a minimum. The rest of core EU suffered greater losses but almost all adopted a similar policy of lockdowns, testing, mobilization of massive hospitalization, and economic solidarity with the new unemployed. There have been only a few outliers from this model response, for example Hungary that used the pandemic as a pretext for usurpation of power and rule by decree, while Sweden pursued a permissive policy rejecting strong restrictive measures by state authorities. At the level of the EU its unprecedented set of 750 billion euro ‘recovery’ measures adopted on 21 July redistributed resources on major scale in favour of the populations hardest hit. 


A common EU biopolitical agenda towards EaP takes shape in two forms. The first is based on material intervetion (namely, through financial assistance packages). Second, the EU further promotes the concept of resilience as a key part of its foreign policy toolkit, which implies a complex of measures to stimulate the self-secured societies among EU’s neighbors. This includes not only technical preparedness (the business of the state), but also enticement of social responsibility among citizens and civil society groups. The EU thus appears to combine the predominantly values-based model of liberalism with technocratic methods of rational and efficient governance.


On the other hand, Russia’s agenda advances its own hybrid version of illiberalism. Domestically, Russia is clearly moving towards a model of social conservatism heavily relying on ‘pastoral power’ – a mixture of religious Orthodoxy and the increasingly sacrosanctified sovereign authority personified by Putin. The reference to God in the new constitution is likely to undermine the idea of the secular state in Russia, and create more space for public roles by the religious authorities. What becomes increasingly clear is that Russian “pastoral power” is anything but biopolitical – it is more aimed at legitimizing the function of the state to send citizens to battlefields than at promoting and taking care of people’s lives. The most recent confirmation for this came from the patriarch Kirill who congratulated the Russian people on the occasion of the anniversary of the beginning of the German-Soviet war in 1941 that took millions of lives. The religious glorification of war serves as an important element of the ongoing militarization of Russian society aimed at raising the potential acceptance of Russian force projection in the future.


This explains another facet of hybridity of Russian illiberal agenda – a special combination of biopolitics and geopolitics. When Putin famously declared the fall of the Soviet Union a major geopolitical catastrophe of the 20st century, he had in mind its biopolitical dimension, arguing that millions of Russians have found themselves beyond the Russian borders and allegedly in need of help and protection from Moscow. Yet when in June 2020 Putin directly called upon countries that seceded from the USSR to return “authentically Russian territories”, he basically had in mind a perspective of a geopolitical reshuffling in the post-Soviet world. The COVID-19 has actually diminished the biopolitical elements in Russian neighborhood policy: in a situation of the real crisis caused by the pandemic, Moscow did nothing to help Russian-speakers living abroad. In this sense the Russian world doctrine remains chiefly declaratory and rhetorical rather than conducive to practical policies.  


Under these conditions EaP countries find themselves in a complex situation with new challenges. First of all there are the repercussions of the global shift towards biopolitical forms of power: nowadays issues of medicine and health care not only become core elements of security and resilience, but in a more general sense are likely to define the sustainability of national sovereignties. In other words, countries struggling for their sovereignty should invest much more in developing biopolitically resilient societies, and this seems to be one of those policy tracks that might bring them closer to the EU. The EU’s decision to support all six Eastern Partner states resonated positively not only in the three associated states (Georgia, Moldova and Ukraine). Armenia noted the EU’s aid arriving alongside nothing from Russia, despite its security guarantees from Moscow. Lukashenko’s attempted denial of the pandemic led local authorities to act in his place, and his re-election bid in August becomes more contested than ever. Georgia seems to be a success story in tackling the pandemic, while Ukraine faces a harsh challenge of qualitatively upgrading its medical infrastructure.


Finally, COVID-19, in spite of some expectations, did not boost a more cooperative behavior between states. On the contrary, as the recent resumption of military confrontation in July between Armenia and Azerbaijan showed, the common epidemiological threat did not prevent the two neighbors from another wave of escalation on the border (to which might be added the hostilities at the Indian-Chinese border in June). Indeed, on the defensive against the common Covid-19 enemy at home, they now appeal to patriotism in the fight against the external enemy. Geopolitical clashes, therefore, are to stay, yet with the global advance of the biopolitical agenda they are to look more and more archaic and jarring.


Comments ()

  1. wangxiao 16 february 2023, 09:52 # 0
    Finally, COVID-19, in spite of some expectations, did not boost a more 藍色小藥丸cooperative behavior between states. On the contrary, as the recent resumption of military confrontation in July between Armenia and Azerbaijan showed, 液態威而鋼 the common epidemiological threat did not prevent the two neighbors from another wave of escalation on the border (to which might be added the hostilities at the Indian-Chinese border in June).犀利士 Indeed,
    1. Sifa 14 march 2023, 11:57 # 0
      Explore the wide range of new design dress in Pakistan at sifa. Sifa brings an amazing collection of new dresses online in all over Pakistan at low prices. So, grab your favorite design from sifa.
      1. Jazmin 14 march 2023, 15:28 # 0
        Reveal your glamour with the stunning Net Dress Designs offered by Jazmin Clothing. Each dress is crafted from the highest quality net fabric and designed to elevate your style for any special occasion. Shop now
          1. Mike Rooney 04 july 2023, 10:48 # 0
            I found this post very exciting. I am also sending it to my friends to enjoy this blog.
            T Birds Jacket Grease

            1. Andrew Mark 06 july 2023, 14:39 # 0
              This is the one of the most important information for me. And I am feeling glad reading your article. The article is really excellent?
              Yellowstone Merchandise UK
              1. Shahtaj Qaiser 12 july 2023, 13:55 # 0
                Discover the latest and most stunning Walima dresses for women. Our exclusie collection and experience in timeless beauty are tailored just for you. Find your favorite dress from Shahtaj Qaiser. Shop now!
                1. Jazmin 12 july 2023, 16:02 # 0
                  Discover the best sale on brands in Pakistan. So come to Jazmin and get a sale on the latest dresses in all over Pakistan with fast delivery. Find your favorite dress in affordable price online today.

                  1. Servis shoes 13 july 2023, 10:51 # 0
                    Sandals for girls are a type of footwear that is designed for young girls. Servis offers its customers the best quality sandals for girls online in all over Pakistan at great prices. So, grab your sandals today.
                    1. ECS 13 july 2023, 11:01 # 0
                      Take a look at a fantastic selection of Ladies Trousers Designs at ECS. Whether you're looking for black or white trousers, our collection has something for everyone. Shop now today.
                      1. Mohagni 13 july 2023, 11:32 # 0
                        Are you Looking for the best Lawn Dress Design online in Pakistan. We offer the latest designed lawn dresses with unique patterns at Mohagni. So, get your favorite lawn dress online today.
                        1. Walkeaze 15 july 2023, 12:34 # 0
                          Walkeaze is the best online store for Shoes for Women in Pakistan. We provide a wide range of quality products for women such as Sandals, Slippers, Heels, and more. Grab your favorite women's shoes today.
                          1. Chinyere 17 july 2023, 22:55 # 0
                            Chinyere offers a unique, stylish collection of Pakistani casual dresses for girls. Our selection includes the latest trends in ladies' dresses Pakistani, ensuring that you always look your best.
                            1. Adoro 17 july 2023, 23:21 # 0
                              Upgrade your wardrobe with the perfect pair of handmade shoes for men. Our collection offers a wide variety of styles and colors for men of all walks of life. Crafted with attention to detail and quality materials, our shoes offer unbeatable comfort, durability, and style
                              1. Mike Rooney 06 september 2023, 14:15 # 0
                                Thanks for a wonderful share. Here is the great example related to you blog.
                                Peter Dinklage She Came to Me Brown Coat

                                1. Raffat 09 october 2023, 07:44 # 0
                                  Searching for a best divorce lawyer in Islamabad? Our experienced legal team is here to provide empathetic and professional assistance during this challenging time.
                                  1. Jewel Galore 28 october 2023, 14:05 # 0
                                    Jewelgalore proudly presents a stunning collection of Pakistani rings . Explore our exquisite range of intricately designed pieces, reflecting the rich cultural heritage and craftsmanship of Pakistan.
                                    1. zarakhan 09 november 2023, 14:31 # 0
                                      Hello there! I'm thrilled to introduce myself as an outreach partner for Soma Shoes Brand. My journey with this incredible brand has been amazing, and I can't wait to share it with you. As a passionate advocate for fashion and sustainability, being part of the Soma Shoes family is a dream come true. check out and experience an amazing shopping indulgence.
                                      1. OSH UNIVERSITY 10 november 2023, 15:58 # 0
                                        Secure your path to a medical career with Osh University, where admission in MBBS opens doors to excellence. Join a community of aspiring medical professionals, guided by expert faculty, and embark on a transformative journey.
                                        1. Andrew Mark 15 november 2023, 16:03 # 0
                                          Excellent article. The writing style which you have used in this article is very good and it made the article of better quality.
                                          Top Gun Tom Cruise Jacket
                                          1. Fannie Walters 29 november 2023, 08:08 # 0
                                            I also wrote an article on a similar subject will find it at write what you think. Kissimmee Termite Control
                                            1. Fannie Walters 02 december 2023, 15:50 # 0
                                              For many people this is the best solution here see how to do it. Orlando Bed Bug Pest Control
                                              1. Fannie Walters 02 december 2023, 15:51 # 0
                                                I am always searching online for storys that can accommodate me. There is obviously a multiple to understand about this. I feel you made few salubrious points in Attributes moreover. Detain busy, awesome career! Oviedo Bed Bug Pest Control