The EU and the Trio in the light of the Russian threats

Michael Emerson

Op-ed No. 2/2022

The current Russian threat to invade Ukraine, aimed also at intimidating Georgia, creates a new political context for the EU to consider how to support more strongly all three Trio partners.

 

This can be done with a clear political distinction between NATO security issues and EU integration processes, even if the two institutions work increasingly closely together. Any Russian diplomat in the Brussels can see that NATO enlargement is not happening, ever since the 2008 Bucharest summit when Europeans declined to support membership action plans for Ukraine and Georgia. Let us suppose, hopefully, that the ongoing negotiations between Russia and the US/NATO/OSCE reach some kind of realistic wording that averts the current threat of Russian invasion of Ukraine. 

 

On the other hand, EU integration for the Trio is a much more elastic and open question. Under these conditions, how should the EU develop its policy towards the Trio? It should surely have a more explicit and positive overall content, but also be tailored to the specifics of the three states. General issues are discussed first, and then something on each of the Trio states individually.

 

Generalities

1. There are current initiatives to be built on, including deepened sectoral integration, notably in relation to the Green Deal and Digital transformation, and the best feature of the recent Eastern Partnership summit, namely organisation of both EU and IFI funding of flagship projects.

 

2. These and other desirable projects could receive increased funding, giving clearer and more substantial meaning to the ‘more for more’ slogan.

 

3. A more novel development move would be to provide for progressive participation in the EU institutions step by step, including in various Council bodies without voting rights, with MPs delegated to the European Parliament, etc. Political dialogue between the EU and the Trio should see the Trio states to unifying their requests and subjecting each other to peer review to curb any policies undermining the reputation of the Trio project.

 

4. More radically the EU should be revising both its enlargement and neighbourhood policies. A more constructive system of incentives is needed, replacing current realities under which requests by the Trio for membership perspectives are simply denied by the EU. A bit more detail is needed for this to be clear.

 

A revised system should keep the present Article 49 of the Lisbon Treaty entitling any European democracy to apply for membership. But the accession process should be redefined with a set of stages assuring progressive integration conditional on political and economic criteria.1 Crucially there should be a penultimate stage in which the candidate state would have qualified for full membership, and would be fully included in all EU policies, funding and institutions, with just two exceptions: no veto powers in the Council and no member of the Commission. This would be to respect the concerns of present member states that further enlargement should not threaten the functionality of the institutions. It would continue until the EU had reformed itself with regard to the two exceptional issues, i.e. curbing veto powers and reforming the Commission in line with the not-yet implemented Lisbon Treaty provision (Commissioners to number only 2/3rd of the number of member states). At this point, the distinction between the penultimate stage and conventional membership would be ended. Encouragingly, the leaders of France, Germany and Italy are already now calling for more qualified majority voting, meaningless veto powers. 

 

Ukraine. While Zelensky’s leadership is somewhat shaky, there is an important bedrock of EU integration policies underway, going beyond the Association Agreement and DCFTA. A major example is the plan to approximate the EU’s Green Deal, with transformative economic and societal implications. This will be extremely expensive, and becomes a prime candidate for the ‘more for more’ treatment. 

 

Moldova. The Sandu presidency and new government have won well-founded plaudits for their impeccably democratic transformation of the Moldovan political system, aimed at profound reform starting with the judiciary. At the same time the economy is very fragile and struggling with the dual crises – Covid and energy supplies, already before the current Russian threats to peace in Europe (even if the latter do not target Moldova explicitly). The EU has already helped to finance imports of gas at much increased prices from Russia, and further conditional support is warranted.  

 

Georgia. Unfortunately, Georgia has become the politically most controversial of the Trio partners, because of decisions widely criticized both at home and in the EU for being undemocratic. The government has now a reputation for delivering ‘bad surprises’ in the form of decisions that the leadership must have known to conflict with European democratic values. The most important for the EU was the intended reneging on electoral commitments made in the agreement of 19 April with EU President Charles Michel; the most recent concerns the abolition of an independent inspectorate. These decisions stand incongruously alongside continuing speeches by the leadership about the intention to submits a formal application for EU membership in 2024. The pity of it is that Georgia scores so well in many policy fields under the DCFTA.

 

What could be done to get Georgia back on the rails? 

 

First, since trust with the EU has been broken, it needs to be re-established, if not the credibility of the Trio is also damaged. There are ample opportunities and formats for political dialogue available at all levels. What is needed to begin with is at least a discrete understanding that there will be no more ‘bad surprises’. More precisely there could be an understanding that when the government might be considering decisions that risk being criticized as contrary to European political values, the topic should be tabled for ‘political dialogue’ before such decisions are taken and announced, to see whether bumps in the road can be smoothed out in a spirit of constructive dialogue. 

 

Second, it could be a good idea for Georgia to reformulate its intended 2024 application for membership broadly along the lines advocated above for a staged accession process (point 4). The present formulation was hardly considered credible even before the recent ‘bad surprises’, and not only for Georgian reasons. The EU itself was, and still is, stuck in a negative position over ‘membership perspectives’ without creating other positive perspectives. The Trio states together could formulate together a common understanding that, while they see the conventional enlargement process is on hold pending internal EU reforms, they could help engineer a new integration dynamic by endorsing the idea of a staged accession process. 

 
 

_______
_______
1. These ideas have been presented in detail in two documents, one in March 2021, https://www.ceps.eu/ceps-publications/balkan-and-eastern-european-comparisons/
 and the second in October 2021, https://www.ceps.eu/download/publication/?id=34206&pdf=A-Template-for-Staged-Accession-to-the-EU.pdf

 

 

Comments ()

  1. SEO 28 february 2023, 18:35 # 0
    Interesting post. I Have Been wondering about this issue, so thanks for posting. Pretty cool post.It 's really very nice and Useful post.Thanks Flights in pakistan
    1. Sifa 14 march 2023, 10:17 # 0
      Sifa offers an amazing collection of ladies ready to wear dresses for girls and women. Grab your favorite ready to wear dress online in all over Pakistan at reasonable prices with fast delivery.
      1. Metro Shoes 14 march 2023, 13:21 # 0
        Metro shoes offers their customers the highest quality block heels and high heels Get the best available pencil heels for womens in Pakistan, today So, buy the best heel shoes for girls online from Metro shoes We bring you only the highest quality heels for girls and high heels for girls
        1. Jazmin 14 march 2023, 14:32 # 0
          Jazmin Clothing offers a beautifully crafted lawn collection that exudes elegance and comfort. Discover the latest lawn designs at Jazmin Clothing and elevate your wardrobe to new heights of sophistication. Shop now and embrace the summer season in style
          1. Belive 16 march 2023, 09:41 # 0
            Welcome to BELIVE.PK, the online store for mens trousers Pakistan online shopping. All stilish and latest trend pakistani mens trouser are available here.
            1. Chinyere 17 march 2023, 08:37 # 0
              Chinyere is a fashion brand for women who appreciate quality and style. Chinyere is one of the best clothing brands for women and offers a range of casual, semi-formal, and formal clothing options to suit any occasion. Our garments are designed with care and attention to detail, incorporating global fashion trends as well as traditional styles.
              1. Mohagni 29 march 2023, 12:59 # 0
                Mohagni presents an outstanding collection of Summer Dresses For Girls that captures the essence of grace and glamour. Choose from a variety of colors and style at Mohagni. Order your favorite dress and embrace the summer season in style
                1. کلاه کاسکت 31 march 2023, 14:46 # 0
                  Best motorcycle helmet shop
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت

                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت

                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  کلاه کاسکت
                  1. michsullivan15 16 may 2023, 18:46 # 0
                    Consider hiring roofing contractors venice if you believe it is time to invest in a new roof.
                    1. okbet 03 june 2023, 09:05 # 0
                      Quality posts is the crucial to invite the visitors to visit the web page, that's what this web page is providing.
                      okbet casino
                      1. Main Dewa Kuis 11 july 2023, 09:04 # 0
                        Jangan sia-siakan kesempatan untuk bermain Dewa Kuis dan menguji pengetahuanmu! Bergabunglah sekarang dan nikmati serunya tantangan kuis interaktif di Dewa Kuis. Tunjukkan keahlianmu, naikkan skormu, dan berkompetisi dengan pengguna lainnya. Ayo, mari Main Dewa Kuis dan buktikan dirimu sebagai juara!
                                    1. UFABET168GO 08 august 2023, 04:40 # 0
                                      <a href="ufabet168 vip">ufabet168 vip เว็บตรงแทงบอล และคาสิโนออนไลน์ดีที่สุด สล็อต PG ทดลองเล่น เล่นฟรีทุกค่าย เล่นได้ก่อนใคร
                                      1. Mike Rooney 23 august 2023, 13:01 # 0
                                        Thanks for a wonderful share. Here is the great example related to you blog.
                                        Bomber Jacket Barbie
                                        1. Andrew Mark 24 august 2023, 14:53 # 0
                                          This is excellent article, thank you for the share! This is what I am looking for, hope in future you will continue sharing such an superb work.
                                          Barbie Jacket
                                          1. shateroone 04 september 2023, 11:09 # 0
                                            مكافحة الحشرات هي مجموعة من الإجراءات التي يتم اتخاذها للحد من تأثير الحشرات على البيئة وصحة الإنسان والحيوانات والمحاصيل الزراعية. تشمل هذه الإجراءات استخدام المبيدات والطرق البيولوجية الآمنة والمتطورة لمكافحة الحشرات المنتشرة في المناطق الحضرية والمزارع والغابات. قد تستخدم المكافحة الحشرية الكيميائية مبيدات حشرية، ولكن الأساليب الحديثة للمكافحة الحشرية أكثر استدامة وصديقة للبيئة وتشمل الصرف الحلزوني، والمصائد الحيوانية، والأساليب الحيوية، والصرف الحيواني والتزمير.
                                            شركة مكافحة حشرات
                                            تحتاج مكافحة الحشرات في الكويت إلى مهارات خاصة وتقنيات متطورة لمواجهة نوعية الحشرات المؤذية المنتشرة في المنطقة، مثل الصراصير والنمل والذباب والبعوض والصراصير الفرنسية والقراد والنمل الأبيض وغيرها. يوجد العديد من شركات مكافحة الحشرات في الكويت التي توفر خدمات شاملة لمنازل ومكاتب ومصانع ومتاجر ومدارس وغيرها من المباني، وتستخدم تقنيات آمنة وفعالة للقضاء على الحشرات، مثل البخار والصفائح اللزجة والأساليب البيولوجية. كما يحتاج الأمر إلى الالتزام بالإجراءات الوقائية للحد من انتشار الحشرات، مثل الحفاظ على النظافة وتهوية المباني والتخلص من القمامة بشكل مناسب والتحكم في الرطوبة.
                                            شركة مكافحة حشرات بالكويت
                                            1. Angel17 07 september 2023, 06:47 # 0
                                              Thanks for sharing this. Keep us updated! replace a shower
                                              1. lily167 06 october 2023, 13:29 # 0
                                                This post is quite beneficial. I am grateful that you have shared it with not only me but also the rest of the globe.
                                                dordle game
                                                1. Raffat 09 october 2023, 07:27 # 0
                                                  Looking for a Court Marriage Lawyer in Islamabad? Our skilled legal experts are dedicated to facilitating seamless court marriage proceedings.
                                                  1. 먹튀검증 10 october 2023, 03:48 # 0
                                                    I have registered with your feed furthermore watch for witnessing your personal exceptional write-ups 먹튀검증
                                                    1. https://therowdylender.com/ 10 october 2023, 03:48 # 0
                                                      When I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox now https://therowdylender.com/
                                                      1. 메이저사이트 10 october 2023, 03:48 # 0
                                                        There’s noticeably a bundle to find out about this. I assume you made sure nice factors in options also. 메이저사이트
                                                        1. 토토사이트 추천 10 october 2023, 03:49 # 0
                                                          Do you know any methods to help reduce content from being ripped off? I’d genuinely appreciate it. 토토사이트 추천
                                                          1. 토토사이트검증 10 october 2023, 03:49 # 0
                                                            Truly, this article is really one of the very best in the history of articles. I am a antique ’Article’ collector and I sometimes read some new articles if I find them interesting. 토토사이트검증
                                                            1. lindamartn15 11 october 2023, 11:28 # 0
                                                              Way cool! Some very valid points! I appreciate you writing this article plus the rest of the website is also very good. credit repair newark nj
                                                              1. simon 18 october 2023, 12:04 # 0
                                                                This is exactly what I needed to see today. Thanks for sharing positivity!" النترا 2023
                                                                1. simon 18 october 2023, 12:04 # 0
                                                                  «Your creativity knows no bounds. This is truly amazing مازدا 6 2023
                                                                  1. say 21 october 2023, 10:25 # 0
                                                                    I have been reading your posts regularly. I need to say that you are doing a fantastic job. Please keep up the great work.
                                                                    1. Being instructor 28 october 2023, 22:41 # 0
                                                                      «Your blog is a treasure trove of positivity, continuously emphasizing that gratitude is the key to a happier and more fulfilling life. I eagerly anticipate learning and growing with your guidance.»
                                                                      1. Being instructor 28 october 2023, 22:41 # 0
                                                                        «Your blog is like a daily dose of sunshine, brightening my life with gratitude and positivity. Thank you for the consistent inspiration.»يارس 2023
                                                                        1. Being instructor 28 october 2023, 22:43 # 0
                                                                          «Your blog is like a guiding star, showing us the way to a brighter, more fulfilled life through gratitude. I'm eager to keep walking this transformative path with your wisdom as my compass.»النترا 2023
                                                                          1. basketball betting 04 november 2023, 04:29(Comment was edited) # 0
                                                                            Very interesting information! Perfect just what I was looking for! My site:basketball betting app
                                                                            1. Mikerooney 10 november 2023, 14:26 # 0
                                                                              This is really an amazing article. Thanks a lot for sharing a piece of wonderful information. keep it up posting. B3 Jacket
                                                                              1. Tuan Cho 11 november 2023, 10:33 # 0
                                                                                Why can't we live together peacefully and equally? I always understand why we wordle have to compete with each other like that. In the end, only the people suffer the most.
                                                                                1. DianaPurwanti 12 december 2023, 07:23 # 0
                                                                                  Siapa bilang poker hanya untuk mereka yang berani mengambil risiko? Bergabunglah dengan kami di situs slot online dan temukan kegembiraan dalam setiap putaran. Rasakan sensasi taruhan yang mendebarkan, kembangkan strategi cerdas, dan menangkan hadiah-hadiah besar. Jangan lewatkan kesempatan ini untuk membuktikan dirimu sebagai pemain poker yang handal. Ayo, mari kita bermain poker di login idn poker dan buktikan kemampuanmu di meja hijau!
                                                                                  1. Vnads 19 december 2023, 06:59 # 0
                                                                                    This article's interdisciplinary approach enriches the conversation, providing a holistic understanding of the subject. Vietnamese Voice Over
                                                                                    1. Vnads 27 december 2023, 06:32 # 0
                                                                                      The captivating storytelling in this article effortlessly educates and mesmerizes, making it an enthralling read. Trà hoa vàng
                                                                                      1. Rohan Rajput 29 december 2023, 13:49 # 0
                                                                                        Connaught Place escorts have a reputation for satisfying their men’s clients. In most of the urban areas in Connaught Place, one can see many professional escort services. The featured Connaught Place Escorts Service are educated and serve their clients more thrill and excitement.
                                                                                        1. Hi88 11 january 2024, 09:35 # 0
                                                                                          1. Kunal Tomar 13 january 2024, 12:11 # 0
                                                                                            Many young guys are nowadays more keen on having sex with a MILF or a mature bhabhi escort in Mahipalpur. And that’s the reason we have a huge collection of housewife Escorts in Mahipalpur with us. These married ladies for sex in Mahipalpur work as part time prostitutes when their husbands and other family members are not around. Their services are more than ordinary as told to us by our genuine bhabhi lovers. These mature escorts in Mahipalpur give all those sex services in Mahipalpur which normally those young sluts don’t offer or do unwillingly. Some examples of these services are cum in mouth, anal sex and role play.
                                                                                            1. Davit Jack 16 january 2024, 15:27 # 0
                                                                                              Every woman's best desire is to look cool and elegant and sophisticated and beautiful and they deserve so by nature, The ladies these days follow magazines, fashion shows, and movies to get inspired and have their best-looking outwear jackets for themselves, at America suits we have the largest selection of women jackets made from genuine leather and faux leather for all the vegans, we also have a wide variety of cotton, wool, women leather outfits and other fabric jackets for all the lovely ladies out there and our size chart is here to select the right size as well, A team of dedicated staff to cater your needs in selecting the jacket as we understand what women want, have the largest collection of leather jackets for women in the United States, United Kingdom, Canada, and Australia. We have Pure and Guaranteed leather in Multiple colors so Shop with us and Get an amazing discount on any product of Women's Leather Jackets we also have Women's Jackets, coats and vests, and blazers to accommodate every need Shop the best Women's Leather Jacket.
                                                                                              1. jsimitseo 31 january 2024, 14:59 # 0
                                                                                                There you can download for nothing, see the first of these information. best concierge doctor
                                                                                                1. Arman underpin 19 february 2024, 08:12 # 0
                                                                                                  Your perspective on the need for a coordinated and proactive approach to counter these threats resonated with me. It's clear that you have a deep understanding of European politics and security dynamics, things to do in pa
                                                                                                  1. SAFETOTO 22 february 2024, 09:12 # 0
                                                                                                    Get $30 off when you buy apple products register here: 바카라 검증
                                                                                                    1. SAFETOTO 22 february 2024, 11:45 # 0
                                                                                                      «Your VIP Pass Awaits! Register Here!»:
                                                                                                      바카라 검증 .com

                                                                                                      1. soniya singhania 23 february 2024, 09:18 # 0
                                                                                                        We have consistently been targeting giving our clients the inevitable sexual delight through particularly made service. Our striking Escort In Goa (Rs: 5500) Free Home Delivery guarantee to achieve every one of your dreams of closeness or going out. Sans protection sensual caress, just penis massage, oral sex, fingering, please face, burst in mouth, numerous balls, just shots, from high-class foreplay service like BSDM, oral sex without assurance, pretend, genital sex, trio, genital scouring, spooning and the rundown continues endlessly as innovativeness and ability of our escorts is boundless.