The State of the Donbass

Nikolaus von Twickel

Op-ed No. 3/2019

The Donbass region of eastern Ukraine is among Europe’s most deadly modern battlefields on which more than 13,000 people have been killed since 2014. But it is also a propaganda war, where many shots are being fired not to kill somebody but send a message – not always across the frontline. And unlike other conflicts in eastern Europe, this one cannot be explained by regional ethnic or religious antagonisms. Tragically, the suffering people of Donbass happen to live at the wrong place at the wrong time.

While the overall death toll is shocking, the broad European public has become comfortably numb about it – as people are dying in much smaller numbers than in 2014 and 2015. Last year, the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) recorded 43 civilian deaths – half as many as in 2017.

While military violence is almost always an unnecessary evil, this one is particularly bizarre in that it occurs with little or no military value. Since the signing of the Minsk Package of Measures in February 2015 (“Minsk II”), both sides have barely moved an inch over the “Contact Line” agreed with French and German help in the Belarusian capital.

Instead, Eastern Ukraine has become a battleground for information warfare. The shootings and killings serve political purposes – the sides want to keep the status quo in order to avoid the agreement’s unsavoury political parts. They may also want to signal the outside world that they are being under attack and convince their domestic audience to put up with wartime constraints.

As the military dimension has receded, the clash of narratives has grown disproportionately. Ukraine is eager to tell the world that it is fighting Russia, who has attacked, invaded and occupied parts of the country since the annexation of Crimea in 2014. For Russia and its proxies in Donbass, there is a civil war in eastern Ukraine. While plenty of evidence has been collected that proves Ukraine right and Russia wrong, the two “People’s Republics” set up in Donetsk and Luhansk serve the purpose of engineering a civil war which would never have broken out without them.

Donetsk and Luhansk are far from being Ukraine’s only Russian-speaking areas. People in Kharkiv, Dnipro, Odessa and even Kiev speak Russian without identifying with Russia. Separatist movements failed, notably in Kharkiv, when local elites sided with the government. In Donetsk and Luhansk, the elites were initially undecided, while the proximity to the border with Russia also played a role.

The purpose of these quasi-states outside Ukraine’s control and entirely dependent on Russian support is clearly to keep the fire simmering without burning down the house. Moscow is doing its best to cultivate anti-Ukrainian sentiment and foster pro-Russian views inside Ukraine while claiming that it respects the Minsk agreement (at least the letter) by not recognizing the “Republics” – although it has recognized its documents in 2017.

Running the “People’s Republics”, on the other hand, has not proven an easy task. It took the Kremlin’s political machine years to contain infighting, corruption and insubordination among local elites. Numerous warlords were killed on the way, the most prominent being Donetsk separatist leader Alexander Zakharchenko, who died when a bomb exploded at his favorite café in August 2018. However, it looks like Zakharchenko’s corrupt clique was replaced by another.

There is a positive message in these difficulties. While Russia possesses more than enough military might to conquer territories in neighbouring countries, it does not necessarily have the power to keep them peaceful and stable. This might deter hardliners in the Kremlin from further military adventures.

However, the longer the “People’s Republics” exist, the harder their reintegration into Ukraine will become, a prospect that is aggravated by Kiev’s current counter-productive trade blockade of the separatist regions. This poses further risks of a higher and graver order. On the one hand, Ukraine might be prompted to retake them by force before it is too late, leading to outright war. On the other hand, Russia might be prompted to recognize and/or annex them. Assumed that there is no military solution, the best path for Ukraine is to become a stable and prosperous democracy that is the more attractive option for the population of the impoverished “People’s Republics”. This is what Kiev with Western policymakers should focus on.

Comments ()

  1. Feko 10 august 2023, 07:23 # 0
    Skibidi toilet is most likely where I found the most relevant material for my investigation. Thank you for publishing; maybe we will see more on this.
    1. Mike Rooney 15 august 2023, 14:25 # 0
      This is a great inspiring article. I am pretty much pleased with your good work. You put really very helpful information.
      Steve Austin Vest
      1. Marilian 17 august 2023, 05:11 # 0
        A good lesson can be drawn from these trials. Russia has the military capability to capture territory in its neighbors, but this does not mean it can maintain peace and stability in run 3
        1. Andrew Mark 17 august 2023, 15:53 # 0
          This is an excellent post I seen thanks to share it. It is really what I wanted to see hope in future you will continue for sharing such a excellent post.
          Eddie Munson Outfit
          1. kelseyradley 24 august 2023, 11:16 # 0
            This is a fantastic, motivational article. I am largely satisfied with your excellent work. You provided some truly good information. Bitlife
            1. gcoaming 24 august 2023, 12:42 # 0
              Bali is home to picture-perfect driving directions beaches, paddy paddies, tropical jungles, and stunning temples. People from all walks of life go to this famous Indonesian island in search of relaxation and adrenaline rushes.
              1. OKBet 19 september 2023, 05:36 # 0
                I Like!!! Really appreciate you sharing this blog post.Really thank you! Keep writing.
                OKBet download
                1. Jazmin Clothing 04 october 2023, 10:57 # 0
                  Are you looking for sale on brands in Pakistan? So come to Jazmin and get a sale on the latest dresses in all over Pakistan with fast delivery. Don't miss out on this opportunity to update your wardrobe with our massive collection. Shop Now!
                  1. Meerak Official 04 october 2023, 11:07 # 0
                    Introducing the latest fashion trend in women's clothing, Meerak presents a stunning new dress designs for women. With a blend of elegance and contemporary style, these dresses are a perfect choice for fashion-forward women. Buy now.
                    1. Adoro 04 october 2023, 11:08 # 0
                      Walk confidently with comfort and style with Adoro's comfortable shoes for women. These shoes are the perfect combination of fashion and function. Our women shoes are designed to provide maximum foot support while giving you the most fashionable look. With our breathable material, you can now look good all day long without ever compromising on comfort. Shop now!
                      1. Servis 04 october 2023, 12:11 # 0
                        Welcome to Servis Online Official Store. Join us and get the best selection of shoes for men and other products. Buy shoes for men online in Pakistan at reasonable Prices from Servis.
                        1. houseofflowers 04 october 2023, 12:29 # 0
                          Experience the beauty and fragrance of a wide variety of flowers at House of Flowers. From vibrant bouquets to elegant floral arrangements, we have the perfect bunch of flowers for any occasion. Explore our collection and bring a touch of nature's splendor into your home or send as a thoughtful gift to brighten someone's day.
                          1. Ammara khan 04 october 2023, 12:29 # 0
                            Explore the best collection of Pakistani Bridal Dresses online at Ammara Khan. We offer the best quality bridal dresses online all over Pakistan at the best prices. So, get your favorite bridal dress online today.
                            1. Walkeaze 05 october 2023, 09:08 # 0
                              Walkeaze brings a fantastic collection of New Shoes Designs for women online in Pakistan. Explore the best quality shoes for women online and get your favorite shoes across Pakistan at the best prices.
                              1. Mohagni 05 october 2023, 09:56 # 0
                                Buy the latest ready to wear dresses online in Pakistan. With a large number of newly designed dresses, Mohani provides the highest quality fabric in various colors and styles. Get your favorite dress and ready to shine.
                                1. Chahyay 05 october 2023, 10:01 # 0
                                  Check out the best mascara in Pakistan with Chahyay. Achieve stunning lashes and dramatic eye looks with our carefully curated selection of top-quality mascaras. Shop now for the perfect mascara from Chahyay Online.
                                  1. The Entertainer 05 october 2023, 11:54 # 0
                                    Explore the newest range of electric remote car at The Entertainer. Providing a variety of toy cars for kids that offer hours of engaging and active play. Find the perfect toys for your children online at the Entertainer.
                                    1. Shahtaj Qaiser 05 october 2023, 12:31 # 0
                                      Elevate your style with the latest Pakistani luxury formals. Our luxury formal wear is designed to make you feel like a true fashion icon. Don't miss out on a chance to make a statement with our stunning collection. Find your favorite dress online today!
                                      1. Borjan 05 october 2023, 14:51 # 0
                                        Borjan bring court shoes for women online in Pakistan. Borjan offer their costumers best quality women court shoes. Shop Now!
                                        1. Raffat 06 october 2023, 08:51 # 0
                                          Looking for a Court Marriage Lawyer in Islamabad? Our skilled legal experts are dedicated to facilitating seamless court marriage proceedings.
                                          1. ecs 06 october 2023, 09:57 # 0
                                            Are you looking for best Pumps Shoes Online? ECS Offer their costumer best pump shoes for women that are best in quality and Comfort. Shop Now!
                                            1. nanipk 11 october 2023, 10:27 # 0
                                              Find out the best kids brand in Pakistan that provides a selection of excellent products for kids. have exceptional quality and attention to detail in everything from trendy apparel and accessories to educational toys and games. Shop now to provide your children with the best style, comfort, and durability.
                                              1. Byrd Franklin 12 october 2023, 06:58 # 0
                                                Good article. Very informative, well balanced, unbiased. mario games
                                                1. Kafas Tourism 12 october 2023, 12:48 # 0
                                                  KafasTourism offers seamless dubai trips from Pakistan, ensuring every detail of your journey is flawless. Experience the magic of Dubai with our expertly planned itineraries.
                                                  1. Jewel Galore 12 october 2023, 19:00 # 0
                                                    Jewelgalore is your premier destination foronline Pakistani jewelry . Explore their exquisite collection and adorn yourself with intricately designed pieces that reflect the cultural richness and artistry of Pakistan.
                                                    1. Deanna Pope 15 october 2023, 10:29 # 0
                                                      For this web site, you will see our account, remember to go through this info. Kissimmee Termite Treatment
                                                      1. Shalamar Hospital 16 october 2023, 14:23 # 0
                                                        Shalamar Hospital is your destination for top neurological care in Lahore, with the best neurologist in Lahore providing expert consultations and treatments.
                                                        1. Melinda Baxter 20 october 2023, 06:01 # 0
                                                          I appreciate you sharing this wonderful content. It's exactly what I was hoping to see, and I really hope you'll keep publishing great posts like this in the future. cookie clicker
                                                          1. 먹튀검증사이트 20 october 2023, 11:01 # 0
                                                            We delight in which outstanding write-up that you've offered for individuals such as all of us 먹튀검증사이트
                                                            1. 먹튀검증 20 october 2023, 11:02 # 0
                                                              You possess position a pivotal offspring… Blesss for making an application: D 먹튀검증
                                                              1. 메이저사이트 20 october 2023, 11:02 # 0
                                                                Appreciate what we have, that’s what my mother always said to me 메이저사이트
                                                                1. 토토사이트 순위 20 october 2023, 11:02 # 0
                                                                  These kinds of bogus promises are usually considerable, helpful envision therefore — I am sure therefore much too 토토사이트 순위
                                                                  1. Deanna Pope 20 october 2023, 12:46 # 0
                                                                    Interestingly you write, I will address you'll find exciting and interesting things on similar topics. Orlando Bed Bug Treatment
                                                                    1. Deanna Pope 20 october 2023, 12:50 # 0
                                                                      Interesting and interesting information can be found on this topic here profile worth to see it. Oviedo Bed Bug Treatment
                                                                      1. Jewel Galore 28 october 2023, 13:41 # 0
                                                                        Elevate your fashion game with Jewel Galore's stone rings for men . These unique pieces add a touch of luxury and individuality to your look, making a bold statement.
                                                                        1. Jamnii 29 october 2023, 20:01 # 0
                                                                          Check out beautiful silk dress at JAMNii. Our collection features stunning silk dress designs and silk suit designs that are perfect for any occasion. Elevate your style with the elegance of raw silk and indulge in the luxury of our carefully crafted pieces. Order Now for the best Silk Dresses from Jamnii
                                                                          1. Kafas Tourism 30 october 2023, 11:16 # 0
                                                                            Kafas Tourism's Al Ain full-day city tour in Abu Dhabi is your gateway to an unforgettable adventure. Let the city's wonders enchant you as you explore its best-kept secrets.
                                                                            1. Ibi bhai 03 november 2023, 16:08 # 0
                                                                              Anchor: mugs

                                                                              Bb: [url=] mugs[/url]

                                                                              Markdown: [mugs](
                                                                              1. Rgallaries 03 november 2023, 17:36 # 0
                                                                                Discover a stunning collection of ceramic mugs online at R Galleries. Shop now for high-quality, stylish ceramic mugs in various designs and colors. Elevate your coffee or tea experience today!
                                                                                1. Mikerooney 08 november 2023, 12:31 # 0
                                                                                  This letter is awesome. I am happy to find it. It's a great post. B3 Leather Jacket
                                                                                  1. meeloun education 09 november 2023, 09:04 # 0
                                                                                      In terms of workload,the UK dissertation is a relatively extensive text project that requires international students to spend a lot of effort preparing.Especially for beginners,completing a UK dissertation requires a significant amount of time and effort from collecting and reading materials.In order to better complete their dissertation,international students must understand the Keane structure and framework of the UK dissertation.A complete dissertation ghostwriting generally includes the following items in its structure.
                                                                                    1. Vicki Stokes 09 november 2023, 14:39 # 0
                                                                                      I am an online part time writer studying in college. I provide to earn my living and to pay for college. I have always faced financial problems, and this was the only way to cover for college. Orlando Bathroom Remodeling
                                                                                      1. OSH UNIVERSITY 10 november 2023, 13:16 # 0
                                                                                        Osh University and national state university are committed to shaping the future of medical professionals in Kyrgyzstan. Their partnership provides an excellent platform for students to excel in the healthcare field.
                                                                                        1. Rental Sport 15 november 2023, 09:30 # 0
                                                                                          Drive with flair in Rental Sport's Ferrari suits. Tailored for racing enthusiasts, our collection merges the thrill of the track with the iconic style of Ferrari, delivering a perfect blend of speed, comfort, and unmistakable luxury.
                                                                                          1. jewelgalore 15 november 2023, 14:05 # 0
                                                                                            Jewelgalore showcases the beauty of jewellery from Pakistan . Explore their collection to discover intricately designed pieces that reflect the cultural richness and craftsmanship of the region.
                                                                                            1. Rental Sport 21 november 2023, 09:54 # 0
                                                                                              Experience the thrill of the track in a Ferrari racing suit from Rental Sport. Elevate your racing game with our premium collection, ensuring both style and performance for an unforgettable drive.
                                                                                              1. Shalamar Hospital 21 november 2023, 09:55 # 0
                                                                                                Shalamar Hospital, home to the best neurosurgeon in Pakistan , provides a commitment to excellence in neurological care, giving patients the highest level of expertise and treatment.