Towards a Wider Europe

Michael Emerson

Op-ed No. 1/2019

Georgia, Moldova and Ukraine would like to find ways to reinforce their European integration ambitions, currently based on their Association Agreements and DCFTAs with the EU. Given the impasse over demands by these three states for 'membership perspectives', the question is whether there are other routes that could usefully by followed for the time being. Possible answers lead into a chain of linked issues concerning the future of the EU's neighbourhood policy and Eastern Partnership, and conditions for possible future enlargement (first of all for the Balkans).

There are some initiatives emerging on how possibly to reinforce the AA/DCFTAs. One track is to examine the scope for deeper sectoral policy integration in such areas as energy, digital, customs and justice cooperation, as advocated by Ukraine, to which might be added cyber defence. A second complementary track can look at ways to enhance institutional relationships with the EU. This may involve more extensive ministerial dialogues with the European Commission, where Georgia has been making some progress. Another idea for which Norway, Iceland and Liechtenstein provide a precedent in the framework of the European Economic Area (EEA) is for these states to join in selected informal meetings of the EU sectoral Councils. A further more ambitious idea might be accession to the EEA itself. Bundling some such ideas together might provide the basis to build on the AA/DCFTAs with second-generation Agreements, which might for example be branded as AA+.

To be sure such ideas, to be credible, would need to be based on a good record of implementation of the existing AA/DCFTAs, which would need more time still to be confirmed, notably following recent or imminent elections in all three states.

This leads on into the question how the European Neighbourhood Policy might be revised or better restructured in the light of the demise of the original ENP concept of some 15 years ago. Both East and South neighbourhood regions have broken into pieces, most drastically to the South. The East is split between the three AA/DCFTAs and the other three Eastern Partners, two of which joined the Eurasian Economic Union; yet the Eastern Partnership itself still has value. As for the South Mediterranean, the years since the Arab Spring of 2010 have tragically seen much convulsed in violence, terrorism and war, linking to migration crises. The few states that retain the objective of deeper relations with the EU, such as Morocco and Tunisia, have held exploratory negotiations for DCFTAs with the EU, yet without positive outcomes.

At the same time, the EU has been extending and deepening its set of economic policy instruments open to the participation of all European neighbouring states interested and willing to integrate more fully with the EU (e.g. common rules of origin in free trade, energy and transport policies, and much else). This provides the basis for developing what might be called a Wider Europe policy concept, to replace the obsolete ENP.

This would not be to prejudice the pre-accession processes of the Balkan states, while still recognising that in terms of current developments the Balkans have now in some respects to catch up with the advanced DCFTA model. But this also leads into the question of how and when the presently stagnating enlargement process might be credibly got back on track. One aspect of this question links to the quite impressive advances of the so-called ‘multi-speed Europe’, consisting notably of the euro, Schengen and defence domains. These actual or proposed systemic developments have variable geographic coverage, with all cases seeing less than all member states participating, leaving a ‘basic EU’ consisting mainly of the single market and the political processes of the institutions. As President Macron has hinted, such developments combined with some other reforms of the EU (e.g. extended qualified majority voting in the Council), might pave the way to resume the enlargement process.

Now is a good time for discussing such ideas, developed in more detail elsewhere, in view of the renewal of the European Parliament and Commission in the course of 2019. The AA/DCFTA states could well take advantage of this open political window to advance their own ideas into the debate.

In conclusion, it is suggested that a major debate be engaged around three linked propositions:

  • Enhancement of the AA/DCFTAs with an AA+ formula that deepens the integration process;
  • Reconceptualisation of the existing neighbourhood policy into a Wider Europe policy, embracing all European states willing to adopt EU standards and values;
  • Restoring credibility to the enlargement process alongside systemic reform of the EU, including the multi-speed Europe.

Comments ()

  1. wangxiao 16 february 2023, 09:39 # 0
    in view of the奇力片 renewal of the European Parliament and Commission in the course 威而鋼30粒瓶裝 of 2019. The AA/DCFTA犀利士藥局 states could well take advantage of this open political window to advance their own ideas into the debate.
    1. Aspire Bedding 29 may 2023, 16:10 # 0
      With a broad selection of high-quality bedding products, Aspire Bedding is among the best sheet brands in Pakistan. The best materials are used to make their bed sheets, which come in various designs and sizes to suit every need. Aspire Bedding has gained a reputation for its exceptional customer service and timely delivery of orders. Aspire Bedding is the best place to go if you want luxurious and comfortable bed sheets in Pakistan.
      1. Mannat Clothing 30 may 2023, 14:41 # 0
        Mannat Clothing is one of Pakistan's best online clothing store that provides online shopping for women. Mannat Clothing offers a wide range of clothes to choose from, including both casual and formal wear.
        1. Panache Apparel 30 may 2023, 16:11 # 0
          Indulge in the allure of Pakistani dresses online at Panache Apparel. From traditional attire to contemporary ensembles, find a captivating range of outfits that effortlessly fuse cultural heritage with modern fashion sensibilities.
          1. Qhaaf Bedding 30 may 2023, 20:46 # 0
            Qhaaf Bedding is a popular online store in Pakistan that offers a diverse selection of bedding products at affordable rates, such as their exclusive bridal bed sheet sets. Their highly competitive prices allow customers to find an ideal bridal bed sheet set with price in Pakistan that meets their financial constraints. These sets are offered in various sizes and designs, adding an elegant touch to any bedroom aesthetic.
            1. crowdedwalrus 28 july 2023, 09:46 # 0
              Just as the global undercuts the 'nation', so it also undercuts the idea of 'super-nation' and provides basis for other identities and other potential polarisations and possibilities slope unblocked.
              1. Feko 10 august 2023, 07:22 # 0
                This post is probably where I obtained the most helpful material for my study, and backrooms game's the one I'm looking at right now. Thank you for sharing, and perhaps there will be more updates on this.
                1. Marilian 17 august 2023, 05:13 # 0
                  There is a silver lining to these storms. Russia's military is strong enough to take territory in its neighbors, but it may not be strong enough to maintain peace and stability there. amanda the adventurer
                  1. llucklinn 13 september 2023, 05:41 # 0
                    magic tiles 3 is closely associated with the EU's policy of enlargement. This policy aims to bring stability, democracy, magic tiles and prosperity to countries in Europe by offering them the possibility of becoming EU members. Enlargement has been a significant aspect of the EU's history since its inception.
                    1. Master Fabrics 01 march 2024, 12:56 # 0
                      Trust Master Fabrics to provide you with the best fabric for mens shalwar kameez. Our extensive range of fabrics offers superior quality, durability, and style, making every outfit a statement piece.

                    2. OKBet 19 september 2023, 05:35 # 0
                      I finally found great post here.I will get back here. I just added your blog to my bookmark sites.
                      OKBet careers
                      1. 먹튀검증사이트 22 september 2023, 04:44 # 0
                        Spot on with this write-up, I must say i believe this excellent website needs much more consideration. 먹튀검증사이트
                        1. 먹튀검증 22 september 2023, 04:44 # 0
                          Pls look into my site also and make me aware how you feel.: D. 먹튀검증
                          1. 메이저사이트 22 september 2023, 04:44 # 0
                            So allow me to reword this…. Thank YOU for the meal!!! But yeah, thanx for spending the time to discuss this matter here on your website. 메이저사이트
                            1. 22 september 2023, 04:45 # 0
                              Thanks for fantastic info I was searching for this information for my mission.
                              1. lee merrty 28 september 2023, 07:38 # 0
                                Advocate for the inclusion of diverse emoji! Employ the technique of copy-pasting in order to include emoticons into written text. This study aims to examine a range of innovative collections, including Smileys, Activities, Sports, Symbols, and other related categories.

                                1. Couro 01 march 2024, 12:25 # 0
                                  Complete your look with our selection of mens belts from Crafted from the finest materials, these belts are the perfect finishing touch to any outfit.
                                2. koserty 02 october 2023, 11:05 # 0
                                  Abandon cables and benefit from accessible printing. snow rider 3d
                                  1. Meerak Official 04 october 2023, 10:49 # 0
                                    It's that time of year again! The season end sale is now live at the Meerak store. Get up to 50% off in stores and online, which means significant discounts on all your favorite Dresses! Get in quickly and take advantage of these fantastic deals before they're gone! Hurry, the sale ends soon!
                                    1. Jazmin Clothing 04 october 2023, 10:52 # 0
                                      Discover the elegance and sophistication of Jazmin Clothing, a leading ready to wear dress with a unique blend of traditional and modern styles. Jazmin provides a large number of party dresses online in Pakistan.
                                      1. Servis 04 october 2023, 12:00 # 0
                                        Servis Shoes is a leading online store that offers Sneakers for men and other products at the lowest prices. Our product range includes Sneakers for men, Sandals, Chappals, Casual Wear & Formal Wear, Sports Shoes, and Peshawari Sandals in various sizes. Our collection is updated regularly so that you have the latest designs at your disposal.
                                        1. Ammara khan 04 october 2023, 12:20 # 0
                                          Buy the best Party Wear Dresses for Girl online all over Pakistan from Ammara Khan at the best prices. Discover a wide range of the latest party wear dresses online at Ammara Khan. So, grab your favorite party dress with quick delivery.
                                          1. houseofflowers 04 october 2023, 12:25 # 0
                                            At House of Flowers, we offer a stunning collection of flower gift that are perfect for any occasion. From vibrant bouquets to elegant arrangements, our skilled florists create beautiful designs that will leave a lasting impression. Browse our selection and bring joy to someone's day with the gift of flowers from House of Flowers.
                                            1. Walkeaze 05 october 2023, 09:04 # 0
                                              Are you looking for the best Shoes Brands in Pakistan? Walkeaze brings an amazing collection of shoes for women online in Pakistan. Explore the variety of women's shoes online and get your favorite shoes at the best prices.
                                              1. Mohagni 05 october 2023, 09:53 # 0
                                                Discover the perfect winter collection to keep you warm and fashionable all season. Our carefully selected collection includes the newest winter fashion trends. Shop now to add our top picks to your winter wardrobe.
                                                1. Chahyay 05 october 2023, 09:58 # 0
                                                  Find the perfect Pret wear at Chahyay. Browse our collection and get the best Quality Pret dresses that will make you shine at any event. Shop now.
                                                  1. The Entertainer 05 october 2023, 11:50 # 0
                                                    Explore the latest Collection of car toys at The Entertainer. Our selection includes kids; toy cars that offer hours of active play. Shop online today to find the best car toys for your children.
                                                    1. Shahtaj Qaiser 05 october 2023, 12:25 # 0
                                                      Shahtaj Qaiser is one of the top women clothing brands in Pakistan. Discover your favorite outfit and upgrade your style with this unique and stylish collection. Stay on-trend with the latest fashion from Pakistan's most famous designers. Shop now!
                                                      1. Borjan 05 october 2023, 14:48 # 0
                                                        Discover the latest collection of women pump shoes at Borjan. Our stylish and comfortable pumps are designed to elevate your style and provide all-day comfort. Explore our wide range of pumps shoes for every occasion and find the perfect pair that suits your style. Shop now at Borjan.
                                                        1. Raffat 06 october 2023, 08:24 # 0
                                                          Rafat Law Associates: Your trusted source for the Family lawyer in Rawalpindi. With a proven track record in handling diverse family matters, they offer expert legal support with professionalism and compassion.
                                                          1. ecs 06 october 2023, 09:54 # 0
                                                            Discover our stylish and comfortable slippers for girls, available now at ECS. From cozy indoor options to cute outdoor styles, our selection has something for everyone. Shop now and take advantage of our special offer.
                                                            1. nanipk 11 october 2023, 10:23 # 0
                                                              Explore the Best Kids Brands in Pakistan. provides trendy clothing and best accessories for kids. You will find the most suitable choices for your little ones and help them look their best. Shop now!
                                                              1. Samantha Gel 12 october 2023, 03:47 # 0
                                                                The concept of «Towards a Wider Europe» reflects the EU's commitment to extending its values and influence to neighboring countries and, in some cases, offering a path to potential EU membership. However, the process of enlargement and closer cooperation is complex, and countries seeking EU membership must undergo significant political, economic, and legal reforms to meet the EU's standards and requirements. Additionally, EU enlargement has faced various challenges and debates regarding the pace and scope of expansion.

                                                                Gel / Painters Parramatta
                                                                1. Kafas Tourism 12 october 2023, 12:42 # 0
                                                                  KafasTourism is your trusted partner for seamless travel and tours. Explore the world with confidence, as we curate unforgettable experiences just for you.
                                                                  1. jewelgalore 12 october 2023, 18:52 # 0
                                                                    Elevate your fashion game with Jewelgalore's exquisite jewelry online in Pakistan . Browse through their wide range of beautifully crafted pieces, conveniently available for you to explore and purchase from the comfort of your home.
                                                                    1. Shalamar Hospital 16 october 2023, 14:15 # 0
                                                                      Located in Lahore, Shalamar Hospital is a distinguished Lahore hospital known for its exceptional medical care, setting high standards in healthcare services.
                                                                      1. Jewel Galore 28 october 2023, 12:31 # 0
                                                                        Explore a stunning collection of mens rings at Jewelgalore. Discover elegantly crafted pieces that add a touch of sophistication and style to men's fashion.
                                                                        1. Jamnii 29 october 2023, 17:19 # 0
                                                                          Check out beautiful raw silk dresses design at JAMNii. Our collection features stunning silk dress designs and silk suit designs that are perfect for any occasion. Elevate your style with the elegance of raw silk and indulge in the luxury of our carefully crafted pieces. Order Now for the best Silk Dresses from Jamnii
                                                                          1. kafastourism 30 october 2023, 11:10 # 0
                                                                            Explore the vibrant heart of the UAE with KafasTourism's dubai city tours. Immerse yourself in the captivating allure of Dubai city, where tradition meets modernity.
                                                                            1. Tina Heussaff 02 november 2023, 10:22 # 0

                                                                              Mrs. Tina
                                                                              -->Sydney av consultants
                                                                              1. Theodore Evans 08 november 2023, 04:50 # 0
                                                                                I think this post is very helpful and full of useful information. So, I'd like to thank you for all the hard work you put into writing this article fnaf
                                                                                1. meeloun education 09 november 2023, 08:47 # 0
                                                                                  In English Essay writing, a good opening layout is crucial for attracting readers' attention and guiding them into the Essay theme. Here are some suggestions on how to make a good opening layout for English Essay ghostwriting
                                                                                  1. OSH UNIVERSITY 10 november 2023, 13:00 # 0
                                                                                    As a leading state university , Osh University is committed to providing accessible and quality education to a broad spectrum of students, making it a preferred choice for those seeking higher education.
                                                                                    1. Rental Sport 15 november 2023, 09:26 # 0
                                                                                      Unleash your full potential with Rental Sport's cutting-edge suits for racing . Our premium selection guarantees a perfect fit, providing the comfort and flexibility you need to conquer the track with confidence.
                                                                                      1. jewelgalore 15 november 2023, 13:31 # 0
                                                                                        Discover the allure of Pakistani jewellery online at Jewelgalore. Find a wide selection of intricately designed pieces that showcase the artistry and cultural richness of Pakistan, all conveniently available for you to explore and purchase.
                                                                                        1. Rental Sport 21 november 2023, 09:48 # 0
                                                                                          Elevate your racing experience with Rental Sport's premium race suit options. Whether you're a seasoned pro or a novice, our high-quality race suits ensure optimal comfort and performance on the track.
                                                                                          1. Shalamar Hospital 21 november 2023, 09:52 # 0
                                                                                            Shalamar Hospital, your trusted Pakistan hospital, delivers high-quality healthcare services, prioritizing the health and recovery of every patient it serves.
                                                                                            1. Will Saldana 28 november 2023, 05:54 # 0
                                                                                              I was just looking for information on the web when I came across your post io games

                                                                                              1. WATERMELON GAME 11 december 2023, 06:12 # 0
                                                                                                When I'm in a bad mood, I like to play games since they are entertaining, and afterward, I always feel better about myself. If you've never done so, you should give it a go at least once.
                                                                                                1. lee merrrty 11 december 2023, 06:16 # 0
                                                                                                  Quickly put your vocabulary to the test with contexto. Try your hand at guessing the secret word today—you have infinite chances! Have fun while exercising your intellect.
                                                                                                  1. farhan set 13 december 2023, 13:46 # 0
                                                                                                    Secure Valuable and Sentimental Items: If you have valuable or sentimental items, transport them in your personal vehicle for added security. This may include valuables related to your auto or luxury car, such as collector's items or memorabilia. new york bennington
                                                                                                    1. Mary Campbell 14 december 2023, 16:28 # 0
                                                                                                      Agree to this!

                                                                                                      Ms. Mary = Hills solar companies
                                                                                                      1. sophya 15 december 2023, 05:59 # 0
                                                                                                        I think it's good to spend a little time on these kinds of games every now and then because they relieve stress, but it's not a good idea to play them too often and ignore other responsibilities. word wipe
                                                                                                        1. Alex Babao 19 december 2023, 22:52 # 0
                                                                                                          Striking a balance between integration and respect for national sovereignty, addressing economic disparities, and ensuring democratic legitimacy are crucial considerations in the ongoing debate about the future of the EU.

                                                                                                          Alex at Carpet Cleaning Parramatta
                                                                                                          1. OKBet 06 january 2024, 11:07 # 0
                                                                                                            I Like!!! Really appreciate you sharing this blog post.Really thank you! Keep writing.
                                                                                                            OKBet online casino
                                                                                                            1. Jill Steven 10 january 2024, 11:07 # 0

                                                                                                              -jill(Landscaping North Shore)
                                                                                                              1. Hi88 11 january 2024, 09:42 # 0
                                                                                                                1. Sun Sky 11 january 2024, 16:35 # 0
                                                                                                                  1. topmclain 17 january 2024, 05:06 # 0
                                                                                                                    It's important to note that the success of using this political window will depend on various factors, including the nature of the ideas proposed, the political climate, and the level of support and engagement from stakeholders. Overall, it reflects a strategic approach to influencing policy discussions during a period of political change.

                                                                                                                    Mrs. Diana M.
                                                                                                                    Parramatta Bathroom Renovations
                                                                                                                    1. 메이저사이트 17 january 2024, 09:19 # 0
                                                                                                                      I would really like to say 'Thank you", and I also study about 메이저사이트, why don't you visit my place? I am sure that we can communicate well.
                                                                                                                      1. online casinos 24 january 2024, 09:32 # 0
                                                                                                                        Napakahalaga ng iyong mga sulatin sa akin, sana ay ipagpatuloy mo ang paglikha ng mga kapaki-pakinabang na artikulo. jilislot
                                                                                                                        pula puti online
                                                                                                                        1. valentine's day jewelry sale 24 january 2024, 09:45 # 0
                                                                                                                          I admire your writing style, it's very engaging. Please keep the articles coming. valentine's day jewelry promotions
                                                                                                                          valentines jewelry
                                                                                                                          1. meleciaang 25 january 2024, 05:41 # 0

                                                                                                                            Lecia A.
                                                                                                                            food truck booking
                                                                                                                            1. liza memozi 22 february 2024, 11:00 # 0
                                                                                                                              Do you like to play video games? With the added complexity, fall guys is a game that people of all ages can enjoy. Compete against the other players. To win, you must compete in congested areas and navigate difficult chapters.
                                                                                                                              1. blabling2 29 february 2024, 12:51 # 0
                                                                                                                                connect 4 is an interesting game originating from Go, over the years it has gradually become popular and is an indispensable part of the youth of many generations.