What have we learned from Georgia’s presidential election?

Ghia Nodia

Georgian expert Ghia Nodia sums up the election's results.

The recent presidential elections in Georgia were the most competitive and dramatic since 2012, when Georgian Dream (GD) ousted the United National Movement (UNM) from power. In the second round, formally independent candidate Salome Zourabichvili, supported by GD, carried almost sixty per cent of the vote, but in the first round she was neck and neck with Grigol Vashadze, the runner up from the Strength in Unity coalition led by the UNM.

This came as a surprise, especially for GD. The latter appeared to panic, while the opposition developed genuine hopes for a possible victory.

Winning at the expense of what?

The voter turnout surged by more than 20 per cent, from 46.7 per cent in the first round to 56.2 per cent in the second. It appears that a large majority of the new voters gave preference to Zourabichvili.

Why? There are two possible reasons. First, GD used the prospect of Grigol Vashadze’s victory as an opportunity for scaremongering: Vashadze’s victory would mean the return of Mikheil Saakashvili and new turmoil. One of GD’s MPs said that Vashadze’s presidency would cause a civil war.

The campaign was extremely vicious from both sides, with parties presenting the possible victory of the other side in apocalyptic terms. It appears that in this, GD was more successful.

On the other hand, facing the threat of defeat, GD did things it refrained from doing before.

While there were violations throughout the campaign, international and Georgian observers reported that standards declined considerably between the two rounds, assessing this as the worst elections on GD watch.

Nine days before the second round, the prime minister announced a plan to write off the debts of 600 thousand people who were unable to pay back their loans to private banks. It was explained that Cartu bank which belonged to Bidzina Ivanishvili, the leader of GD, would ‘buy’ these loans and then annul them (it was not disclosed how much the bank was going to pay for the transaction).

The opposition and observers called the move an especially blatant case of vote-buying, though the government simply shrugged the allegations off.

Observer organizations also reported numerous and repeated incidences of people holding government jobs being pressured. People were reportedly threatened with losing their jobs unless they vote for the governmental candidate.

Outside the precincts, ruling party representatives diligently checked whether such voters indeed showed up, and afterwards invited them to their cars, allegedly in order to repay their loyalty with cash.

Maybe it were these methods that were decisive in bringing victory to the ruling party favorite, but that cannot be proven.

Why the fuss?

The elevated tensions appear paradoxical because, following the 2010 and then 2017 amendments to the Constitution, the presidency has become a purely ceremonial position. These were also the last direct elections of the president. These elections were, however, a window into the parliamentary elections expected in 2020.

The credibility of the GD government had visibly suffered during the year. The sense of crisis was indirectly confirmed in May when Bidzina Ivanishvili unexpectedly decided to return to public politics by taking up the position of the chairman of the ruling party.

He had widely been believed to be the informal ruler of Georgia. However, he denied this and had expressly ruled out the possibility of a comeback unless things went really bad.

Under the circumstances, a defeat in the presidential polls might be seen as the beginning of the end for GD’s rule, creating a momentum for the opposition and deepening divisions within the ruling party.

For the time being, GD forestalled such a scenario. However, the elections exposed a fundamental vulnerability.

By using the methods it did, GD wasted any remaining moral capital it had in comparison to its arch-rival, the UNM. Moreover, in the parliamentary elections, the UNM will not be the only contender, and the “us against Misha” message will be more difficult to sell.

Can the opposition win?

However, one can come to a different conclusion: if GD won this time, it can do the same to win in 2020. This brings us to a great overarching question in Georgia’s politics: With a single party in control of all the levers of power, does the opposition have any realistic chances of winning the elections at all, even if it becomes more popular than the ruling party?

Many people were skeptical of this in the final years of Mikheil Saakashvili’s rule, that’s why GD’s victory in the 2012 elections came as a big surprise.

But those were exceptional circumstances: The administrative resources controlled by the party in power was evened out by the immense personal wealth of the contender, Bidzina Ivanishvili.

Everybody agreed that without this, the opposition’s case would be hopeless. But this time, both administrative resources and personal wealth are on the same side, and Georgia has nobody even close to Ivanishvili to balance that.

After the first round, people started to believe that the opposition can win even when the playing field is far from even. Now the doubts have returned.

In a fairly poor country like Georgia, if the things become really dangerous for the incumbent regime, the government and the ruling oligarch can still afford to intimidate and/or bribe several hundred thousand people to clinch the victory.

How much stronger should the opposition be in order not to allow that to happen? The question still hangs in the air.

What about the opposition?

Despite the loss, the election became a victory of sorts for the United Opposition coalition created around the UNM. It disproved a popular assumption that the UNM is unable to extend its support beyond its base of devoted loyalists.

Many people who appeared to have abandoned the UNM for good voted for Vashadze this time.

This was arguably a primarily negative vote against the incumbent power. Nevertheless, people still gave preference to the UNM over other contenders.

Can it develop this success further? As in the past, its supposed leader Mikheil Saakashvili is both an asset and a liability. There may be some tensions within the faction already.

As soon as the exit polls signalled Zourabichvili’s victory, Saakashvili called for the election results not to be recognised, and the start of a civil disobedience campaign.

Grigol Vashadze initially rebuked him by saying that this was just one person’s personal opinion and the coalition has to make a collective decision.

The next day, however, the coalition announced that it considered the elections rigged and on 2 December would convene a protest rally demanding early parliamentary elections. Will this tactic bear any fruit, or will it eventually damage the resurgent coalition itself? At this point, the second assumption looks stronger.

The election result challenged another popular assumption as well. The people calling themselves shuashisti(people in the middle) contend that Saakashvili has become so toxic that its party will never be able to win, so the breakthrough can only be achieved by a third force that is not related to either GD or the UNM.

We have been hearing this for at least five years; in the meantime, a number of claimants to this third force emerged, with none of them inspiring much confidence. European Georgia is the most successful so far – it’s candidate, David Bakradze, gained a respectable though not too impressive 11 per cent in the first round.

But it being a splinter group of the UNM, many shuashisti do not consider them ‘third’ enough. David Usupashvili, the former chairman of parliament, campaigned that GD and the UNM are equally bad: he got little over 2 per cent.

Things are thus quite uncertain on the opposition’s side as well, which may be the best hope for Bidzina Ivanishvili. However, Georgia’s recent history has taught us that a lot can change in the two years leading up to the parliamentary elections. So far, the status quo is preserved, but it has become more precarious.


Comments ()

  1. wan785 16 february 2023, 09:35 # 0
    ncertain on the opposition’s side as well, 必利勁副作用 which may be the奇力片 best hope for Bidzina Ivanishvili. However, Georgia’s recent history 德國黑螞蟻生精片 has taught us that
    1. seo 16 march 2023, 11:42 # 0
      As my business is in the field of publishing books, I could say that out of all the printing services that I’ve experienced, this one is the best. With an affordable price and quality products, I could stay with them as long as I am able to. https://www.digitekprinting.com/ their site to see all of their services.
      1. okbet 03 june 2023, 09:27 # 0
        This is really a nice and informative, containing all information and also has a great impact on the new technology. Thanks for sharing it,

        online casino using gcash
        1. Mike Rooney 13 june 2023, 10:53 # 0
          Awesome blog. I have read and thought about what you said. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work! Jake Foy Ride Black Vest
          1. Диета 15 june 2023, 15:26 # 0
            1. 토토사이트 26 june 2023, 08:43 # 0
              Very nice article, I enjoyed reading your post, very nice share, I want to twit this to my followers. Thanks!.. 토토사이트
              1. https://totovera.com/ 26 june 2023, 08:44 # 0
                A lot of times it’s hard to get that “perfect balance” between usability and visual appeal. https://totovera.com/
                1. 메이저사이트 26 june 2023, 08:44 # 0
                  The overall look of your site is wonderful, as well as the content! 메이저사이트
                  1. https://mymelee.com/ 26 june 2023, 08:44 # 0
                    I would repeat that we site visitors are quite blessed to live in a useful community with many marvellous individuals with helpful principles. https://mymelee.com/
                    1. Shahtaj Qaiser 12 july 2023, 14:56 # 0
                      Explore Shahtaj Qaiser's collection of beautiful Pakistani bridal dresses for Barat ceremony. Discover a range of traditional and modern designs, carefully crafted with attention to the little things. Enhance your bridal appearance with our lovely handcrafted ensembles. Shop now!
                      1. Jazmin 12 july 2023, 16:30 # 0
                        Looking for stylish and trendy Net Dresses? Jazmin Clothing has got you covered! Our latest collection of net dresses for ladies is designed to make you feel confident and stylish. So, grab your favorite net dress online at the best prices.
                        1. Servis shoes 13 july 2023, 11:06 # 0
                          Servis brings an amazing collection of Leather Wallet for Men online in Pakistan. Available in a variety of colors, this wallet is a must-have for anyone who values organization and style. So, grab your favorite wallets online today.
                          1. ECS 13 july 2023, 12:34 # 0
                            Shop the latest collection of slippers for ladies online at ECS. Discover the newest collection of stylish and trendy women's slippers online at the best prices. Find the perfect addition to your wardrobe.
                            1. Walkeaze 15 july 2023, 13:02 # 0
                              Buy the best quality Girls Backpack online in Pakistan. Walkeaze brings an amazing collection of leather backpacks for girls online at the best prices. So, grab your favorite backpack online across Pakistan.
                              1. Adoro 17 july 2023, 23:29 # 0
                                Upgrade your fashion with Adoro's incredibly comfortable casual shoes for women. Our range of styles and colors will make you stand out from the crowd. Whether you’re heading to work, attending a function or just hanging out with friends, Adoro has the perfect pair of shoes that combine comfort and style for any occasion. With Adoro, You can always enjoy both comfort and fashion together!
                                1. Himery 10 august 2023, 07:19 # 0
                                  Explore the latest assortment of fashionable ansnow rider 3d contemporary women's slippers available for purchase on the internet at competitive costs. Discover the ideal complement to enhance your attire.
                                  1. Andrew Mark 13 september 2023, 16:08 # 0
                                    This is the one of the most important information for me. And I am feeling glad reading your article. The article is really excellent?
                                    Freddie Mercury Concert Yellow Jacket

                                    1. 메이저사이트 추천 09 october 2023, 07:10 # 0
                                      Thanks for the blog loaded with so many information. Stopping by your blog helped me to get what I was looking for. 메이저사이트 추천
                                      1. 토토사이트 추천 09 october 2023, 07:11 # 0
                                        Hello its my first time to commenting anywhere, when i read this article i thought i could also create comment due to this good 토토사이트 추천
                                        1. lindamartn15 26 october 2023, 23:03 # 0
                                          I believe you might use a few more images to help convey your point home a little more, but other than that, this is an excellent blog. A fantastic read. I'll surely return. pool installation bradenton
                                          1. meeloun education 09 november 2023, 08:25 # 0
                                            When writing assignments, many international students tend to overlook important steps, either deviating from the topic or lacking sufficient arguments, and even have a series of serious problems such as wording and logical errors. If there is still a considerable amount of time to check after writing, then you still have the opportunity to correct some errors. However, if time is tight and it is not possible to conduct detailed checks, it will definitely be difficult to achieve a good grade in this assignment. Next, the editor will share with the students some skills of Assignment ghostwriting australiaway.org/a/assignmentdaixie/, hoping to be helpful to everyone.
                                            1. Fahad Seo 20 december 2023, 02:04 # 0
                                              Breaking down large files into smaller data streams and sending them concurrently improves transfer speed. This approach leverages available bandwidth more effectively. apps like xender

                                              1. AlikaAryani 04 january 2024, 06:38 # 0
                                                Tunggu apa lagi? Ayo, bergabunglah dengan situs dash88 sekarang dan rasakan kegembiraan tak terbatas dalam permainan poker yang memikat! Bersainglah dengan pemain handal dari seluruh dunia, asah strategi poker Anda, dan raih kemenangan yang mengesankan. Dengan fitur yang mengagumkan, bonus menarik, dan layanan pelanggan yang responsif kdslot adalah tempat yang tepat untuk mengasah keterampilan poker Anda. Jadi, daftarlah sekarang dan buktikan bahwa Anda adalah pemain poker yang tak terhentikan!
                                                1. OKBet 06 january 2024, 10:58 # 0
                                                  There's no doubt i would fully rate it after i read what is the idea about this article. You did a nice job.
                                                  OKBet philippines
                                                  1. Hi88 11 january 2024, 09:41 # 0
                                                    1. Alex Mark 14 february 2024, 13:24 # 0
                                                      That appears to be excellent however i am still not too sure that I like it. At any rate will look far more into it and decide personally! Pussy888 ดาวน์โหลด apk
                                                      1. Alex Mark 16 february 2024, 14:16 # 0
                                                        A portable fish finder has other benefits too. They are light-weight and simple to use. Plus they let you use a fish finder in eventualities where you will not be able to employ a fixed one. Bk8
                                                        1. Alex Mark 17 february 2024, 11:45 # 0
                                                          Your articles are a testament to your knowledge and passion for the subject. I look forward to each new post. 補習社
                                                          1. Alex Mark 19 february 2024, 13:11 # 0
                                                            “Sometimes I feel like if you just watch things, just sit still and let the world exist in front of you — sometimes I swear that just for a second time freezes and the world pauses in its tilt. Just for a second. And if you somehow found a way to live in that second, then you would live forever.” AE sexy ออโต้
                                                            1. Alex Mark 19 february 2024, 15:03 # 0
                                                              Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting?I have read a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style. Thanks a million and please keep up the effective work. 東京ハプバー ハプニングバー
                                                              1. Alex Mark 21 february 2024, 13:26 # 0
                                                                I'm grateful for the interesting blog. I'm wondering if there's more information like this available. 補習社
                                                                1. john elia 22 february 2024, 13:28 # 0
                                                                  I concede, I have not been on this page in quite a while… anyway it was another bliss to see It is such a significant subject and disregarded by such huge numbers of, even experts. I thank you to help making individuals progressively mindful of potential issues 英國樓市
                                                                  1. Alex Mark 28 february 2024, 12:30 # 0
                                                                    Wow, fantastic weblog layout! How lengthy have you been blogging for? you made blogging glance easy. The full glance of your website is excellent, neatly as the content material! 私人補習
                                                                    1. Alex Mark 06 march 2024, 07:52 # 0
                                                                      Your blog is a hidden gem that deserves wider recognition. Keep sharing your wisdom. 補習社
                                                                      1. john elia 06 march 2024, 13:42 # 0
                                                                        Should you feel think that its hard to, you without a doubt can't; If you don't plan, to have coming up short. Things are liable to astuteness, decrease of hundreds activities are miserable before beginning. 英國樓市
                                                                        1. Alex Mark 07 march 2024, 12:47 # 0
                                                                          I really like your blog. Great article. It's most evident, people should learn before they are able to click
                                                                          1. Alex Mark 08 march 2024, 15:23 # 0
                                                                            I personally like your post; you have shared good insights and experiences. Keep it up. 小學中文補習
                                                                            1. Alex Mark 09 march 2024, 12:09 # 0
                                                                              I needed to thank you for this phenomenal read!!! I unquestionably adored each and every piece of it. I have you bookmarked your site to look at the new stuff you post. nereidi positano
                                                                              1. mrthankyou 13 march 2024, 10:21 # 0
                                                                                Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can't wait to read lots of your posts. 牙醫診所
                                                                                1. Alex Mark 21 march 2024, 14:42 # 0
                                                                                  Your blog is a trusted source of information for me. I rely on it for valuable insights. 補習社
                                                                                  1. Alex Mark 23 march 2024, 12:18 # 0
                                                                                    I needed to thank you for this phenomenal read!!! I unquestionably adored each and every piece of it. I have you bookmarked your site to look at the new stuff you post. situs slot online