Georgia: An Unexpected Expected Crisis

Ghia Nodia

Op-ed No. 20/2019

In the evening of June 19th, I with two other experts took part in a talk-show on a Georgian TV channel. We all agreed that for the moment, the Georgian Dream (GD) party led by Bidzina Ivanishvili, a secretive plutocrat, looked all but impregnable in power and had good chances to win again in the next parliamentary elections in October 2020. Yes, it was losing popularity for being ineffective and increasingly autocratic.

However, it benefitted from controlling all levers of power and weakness of the opposition. In November 2019, it used blatant vote-buying and alleged voter intimidation to help the candidate it supported, Salome Zurabishvili, to win presidential elections. What would have stopped it from doing the same again?

The opposition looked divided and ineffectual. The exiled former president, Mikheil Saakashvili, charismatic but controversial, was still considered the main alternative leader. However, he was too divisive, revered by many but hated by even more. GD could still mobilize some genuine support around a platform of not allowing Saakashvili back in power. Opposition unity was desperately needed, but with Saakashvili as the central figure, it appeared far-fetched.

The task of the government was made easy by a mixed electoral system, which gave 73 out of 150 parliamentary seats to single-mandate constituencies. In 2016, GD won 48 percent in party lists but carried all single-mandate constituencies (two winners were formally independent but supported by GD). That brought it 75 percent of all mandates. Even if its support went down further (as it was expected), they would probably still keep the majority.

However, we also opined that GD could shoot itself in the foot by some stupid little thing, and then God knows what might follow. That stupid little thing actually happened the very next day, and it was a picture: that of a Russian MP, Sergei Gavrilov, sitting in the seat of the speaker of the Georgian Parliament. He was chairing a session of the Interparliamentary Assembly on Orthodoxy, a Russia-sponsored organization. An outrage caused by seeing Gavrilov in the driver’s seat put large crowds in the street.

Apart from the general background of discontent, there was a more specific reason to explain the sharpness of popular reaction. While the GD generally supports the policy of European Integration, there had always been a nagging suspicion that Ivanishvili who made his fortune in Russia had secret pro-Russian sympathies. Many GD activists and allies are openly anti-western. The Gavrilov-in-the-speaker-seat picture fit into this presumption perfectly.

Then, the government added a substantive injury to the insult. During a rally, a radical part of protesters tried to force their way into the inner yard of the Parliament building. That gave the government a legitimate ground to use force but it conspicuously overdid what it had a right to do. Police spent rubber bullets liberally turning it into a man-hunt operation that extended far away from Parliament building. Two people lost their eyes. On the next day, even more people took it to the street.

The protesters had three major demands: resignations of the speaker of parliament, Irakli Kobakhidze, and the minister of internal affairs, Giorgi Gakharia, and the change of the electoral system to a fully proportional one. Kobakhidze resigned and GD pledged to change the electoral system. However, they still drag their feet on Gakharia: giving him up would make them look really weak, and Gakharia is the most effective minister Ivanishvili has. The protesters pledged to keep protesting until they see the minister’s back. So far, they have been doing this for seven consecutive days.

Whatever the final outcome, a lot has changed already. The GD is seriously wounded, even if not lethally yet. After using brutal methods to disperse crowds, they lost their trump card of claiming they are more humane than Saakashvili’s government. Whatever wrong their predecessors did, they have repeated already, without achieving remarkable successes that Saakashvili’s government also had.

Forthcoming change of the electoral system will seriously boost the confidence of the opposition: For the first time, ousting GD through elections started to look realistic. That may still prove difficult as it will need the much higher level of cooperation between different opposition groups; but with the prize within reach, there are greater chances of that happening as well.

The events may be a setback for Saakashvili and his party. These are the largest and most successful protests since 2012, and they were fully independent of him. The protesters are mostly young people who emphatically reject Misha (all political parties, actually, but first of all him). They also expressly repudiate his vision that Ivanishvili can be replaced not by elections, but by some replica of 2003 ‘Rose Revolution’ that Saakashvili had led. The protesters conspicuously distanced themselves from any remotely violent attempts like forcing their way into Parliament and are resolute to keep the rallies peaceful. The narrative that Saakashvili’s party is the only viable alternative to Ivanishvili is effectively broken.

Russia’s so-called “soft power” is another big loser. Apparently, the Russians had a genuine illusion that because Georgians treated numerous Russian tourists kindly their anger at Putin’s policies had largely expired, and it was only Saakashvili’s party that kept the anti-occupation discourse alive. Now we saw that the anti-Russian-occupation sentiment still has a strong mobilizing power irrespective of Saakashvili’s appeal.

Comments ()

  1. Aspire Bedding 29 may 2023, 16:18 # 0
    Experience the ultimate comfort and style with Aspire Bedding's premium bedding collection, designed to elevate your sleep sanctuary to new heights of luxury.
    1. Mannat Clothing 30 may 2023, 15:11 # 0
      Upgrade your wardrobe with Mannat Clothing's affordable and stylish ready-to-wear collection. Their luxury pret wear includes a variety of colors, styles, and sizes, making it easy for every woman to find the perfect outfit for any occasion. From chic tops to flowy dresses, Mannat Clothing has everything you need to look and feel confident and fashionable.
      1. Panache Apparel 30 may 2023, 16:47 # 0
        Embrace a fusion of cultures with Panache Apparel's western dresses in Pakistan. Explore a range of contemporary outfits that seamlessly blend international trends with traditional influences, giving you a unique and fashionable edge.
        1. Qhaaf Bedding 30 may 2023, 21:01 # 0
          Protect your mattress with Qhaaf Bedding's waterproof bed cover. Crafted using high-grade materials, this bed cover not only offers a comfortable sleep but also shields your mattress from spills, stains, and dust, ensuring its longevity.
          1. Mike Rooney 27 june 2023, 10:10 # 0
            Thanks for a wonderful share. Here is the great example related to you blog.
            Edgerunners Jacket
            1. Raymond 27 june 2023, 15:09 # 0
              Surviving an unexpected crisis can be daunting, but it is possible if you are prepared. By following the tips above, you can increase your chances of surviving and thriving in the event of a crisis. It's important to take care of yourself during a crisis. This includes eating, drinking, and getting enough sleep. It's also important to stay connected with your loved ones and to seek help if you need it. Utilize positive self-talk during challenging training sessions to push through mental barriers. Every time you are starting your training you should ask yourself how to start training for a triathlon then start your training.
              1. complaintdull 28 july 2023, 09:49 # 0
                One of the major political problems mentioned is obviously the unresolved conflict with Russia, which has several dimensions and also affects domestic affairs tunnel rush.
                1. kelseyradley 24 august 2023, 11:17 # 0
                  Aspire Bedding's premium line, created to take your sleep sanctuary to new levels of luxury, offers the utmost in comfort and style. Rainbow Friends
                  1. Fulmasculine 24 august 2023, 12:28 # 0
                    The little town of Medora is the drift hunters entry point to Theodore Roosevelt National Park, where the Great Plains meet the beautiful Badlands. Take the 48-mile scenic trip that around the South Unit and starts and finishes in town to get a feel for the area.